Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
OCR GCSE Ancient History (Rome and its neighbours) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
The foundations of Rome: from kingship to republic, 753-440 BC (longer period study)
Unit 2
Hannibal and the Second Punic War, 218-201 BC (depth study)
Unit 3
Cleopatra: Rome and Egypt, 69-30 BC (depth study)
Unit 4
Britannia: from conquest to province, AD 43-c.84 (depth study)
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/45

Saguntum, the Rhone and the crossing of the Alps

Practise 12 exam-style questions on Saguntum, the Rhone and the crossing of the Alps for OCR GCSE Ancient History (Rome and its neighbours). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 12 questions
  • 1–20 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
12 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

Identify two ways in which Hannibal got his army across the River Rhone in 218 BC.

Model answer

He sent Hanno upstream with part of the army to cross secretly and attack the Gauls from behind, and he moved the elephants across on large rafts covered with earth.

Explanation

Polybius (3.42-46) and Livy (21.26-28) describe the boats bought and built, Hanno's flanking force with its smoke signal, the large ships placed upstream to break the current, horses swimming behind the boats and the earth-covered rafts for the elephants. Any two different methods score.

Mark scheme
  1. 2 marks

    Any two of: he bought / collected boats and canoes from the local people and had more made from tree trunks; he sent Hanno (son of Bomilcar) upstream to cross secretly and attack the Gauls on the far bank from behind; Hanno signalled with smoke so that the main crossing could begin at the right moment; large boats / ships were placed upstream to break the force of the current for the smaller boats; horses swam across towed behind the boats (or were carried in boats); the elephants were taken across on rafts covered with earth

    1 mark for each different correct answer, max 2. Allow recognisable spellings. Credit any other historically valid method from Polybius or Livy. Do not credit 'built a bridge' (there was no bridge, though the elephant rafts were made to look like one) or answers about the Alps.

Question 2

5 marks

Passage B

In 218 BC Hannibal's army reaches the River Rhone, where Gallic warriors are waiting on the far bank.

'The whole of the far bank was held by the enemy. To drive them off, Hannibal sent Hanno, the son of Bomilcar, with part of the army, mainly Spaniards, a day's march up the river at nightfall. He was to cross the river as secretly as possible, lead his men round, and attack the enemy from behind when the moment came ... [After crossing,] they lit a fire on high ground, and the smoke signalled that they had crossed and were not far away. When Hannibal saw it, he gave the order to cross at once, so as not to miss the moment ... A line of large ships crossed upstream to take the force of the current, giving calm water to the small boats below ... The Gauls were already alarmed by what was in front of them when a more terrifying shout broke out behind them: Hanno had captured their camp. Attacked from both sides, they broke through where the way seemed most open and fled to their villages.'

Livy, The History of Rome 21.27.1-21.28.4 (adapted)

What can we learn from Passage B about Hannibal's tactics at the River Rhone?

Model answer

The passage shows that Hannibal's tactics at the Rhone were careful and clever. Facing an enemy who 'held' the far bank, he did not simply force a crossing but sent Hanno upstream 'at nightfall' to cross 'as secretly as possible' and attack 'from behind'. This shows that he used surprise and an attack from two directions. The plan was well co-ordinated: Hanno's men signalled with smoke, and Hannibal gave the order to cross 'at once, so as not to miss the moment', which shows good timing. He also thought about practical problems, placing large ships upstream 'to take the force of the current' so that the small boats could cross safely. The result was that the Gauls, 'attacked from both sides', panicked and fled. Overall, Hannibal combined deception, planning and timing to win a difficult crossing.

Explanation

High-level answers pick out details from the beginning, middle and end of the passage (the flanking force, the smoke signal, the timing, the boats against the current and the double attack) and explain what each reveals about Hannibal's tactics. Simply retelling the events earns Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 5 marks

    Levels of response (5 marks, AO3).
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): Response uses a range of fully appropriate details from the passage, which are analysed to draw out relevant characteristics and features and give a detailed and sophisticated evaluation of what we can learn from the source about the specified issue in the question.
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): Response uses some appropriate details from the passage, which are analysed to draw out some of the characteristics and features and evaluate what we can learn from the source about the specified issue in the question.
    Level 1 (1 mark): Response uses few details from the passage and makes a very basic attempt to draw out any of the characteristics and features in relation to the question.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 1 if the answer makes no use of the passage (own knowledge alone does not answer this question).
    Details must be explained, not just copied: credit what each detail tells us about the issue. A Level 3 answer explains a range of details from across the passage; a Level 1 answer only picks out or copies a detail or two. Own knowledge may be used to explain a detail but is not required.
    Candidates are likely to pick out and explain: 'The whole of the far bank was held by the enemy': Hannibal faced an opposed crossing, one of the hardest operations in war; 'sent Hanno ... with part of the army, mainly Spaniards, a day's march up the river at nightfall': he divided his forces and used darkness and distance to avoid being seen; he trusted a reliable officer and chose troops suited to the task; 'cross the river as secretly as possible ... attack the enemy from behind': the plan depended on surprise and an attack from two directions; 'they lit a fire ... the smoke signalled': careful co-ordination by a pre-arranged signal; 'gave the order to cross at once, so as not to miss the moment': good timing and decisiveness; 'A line of large ships ... to take the force of the current': practical planning to protect the small boats; 'Hanno had captured their camp. Attacked from both sides ... fled': the double attack worked and caused panic.

Question 3

5 marks

Passage B

During the climb into the Alps in 218 BC, Hannibal meets a group of local people.

'The people living near the pass plotted together and came out to meet him with treacherous intentions, carrying olive branches and garlands, which almost all the barbarians use as signs of friendship, just as we Greeks use the herald's staff. Hannibal was rather suspicious of this offer and took great care to find out their plans and motives ... He hesitated for a long time, not trusting their word, but he reasoned that if he accepted their offer they might be less likely to attack him, while if he refused they would certainly become his open enemies. So he agreed and pretended to accept their friendship ... Two days later these same people gathered, followed close behind the Carthaginians and attacked them as they were passing through a difficult, steep-sided gorge. Hannibal's whole army would have been utterly destroyed if he had not still been a little uneasy and, foreseeing this, placed the pack animals and cavalry at the front of the column and the heavy infantry at the rear.'

Polybius, The Histories 3.52.3-3.53.1 (adapted)

Using details from Passage B, how accurate do you think Polybius' account of the ambush in the Alps is?

Model answer

Polybius' account of the ambush is probably accurate in its main points. He wrote only about seventy years later and says he questioned men who had been present and crossed the Alps himself, so details such as the attack in 'a difficult, steep-sided gorge' and the order of the column, with 'the heavy infantry at the rear', are likely to come from good evidence. Livy tells the same story, with the false friendship and the strong rear guard, which supports it, although Livy may have copied Polybius. However, some parts are Polybius' interpretation. He could not know exactly how Hannibal 'reasoned' in private, and the claim that the army 'would have been utterly destroyed' is a dramatic judgement that stresses Hannibal's foresight, whom Polybius admired. Overall, the events are believable, but the explanation of Hannibal's thoughts is less certain.

Explanation

Strong answers combine Polybius' methods (survivors, his own journey over the Alps) with details in the passage, separating what he could know (the gorge, the column's order) from what he inferred (Hannibal's private reasoning). Generic praise or criticism of Polybius without reference to the ambush is Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 5 marks

    Levels of response (5 marks, AO3).
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): Response analyses the source by using relevant detail from the source content or historical context to give a more detailed evaluation of the source within its historical context. It draws a thorough and convincing conclusion about its accuracy or reliability based on how the context in which it was created impacts on how it portrays issues or events.
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): Response analyses the source by using relevant detail from the source content or historical context to give a basic evaluation of the source within its historical context. It draws a basic conclusion about its accuracy or reliability based on how the context in which it was created impacts on how it portrays issues or events.
    Level 1 (1 mark): Response analyses the source in a basic way by selecting relevant detail from the source content or historical context.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 1 if the answer reaches no conclusion at all about how accurate or reliable the passage is.
    Full marks need the evaluation to be related to the particular events in the passage, not only general comments about the author. A conclusion that the passage is accurate, inaccurate or partly accurate can all reach Level 3 if it is supported. Treat bare assertions such as 'he was not there' or 'he was biased' with care: on their own they are Level 1.
    Candidates might comment on: Polybius says (3.48) that he questioned men who had been present and crossed the Alps himself to see the country, so his description of a 'difficult, steep-sided gorge' and of the column's order may rest on good evidence; he wrote about seventy years after the events, close enough to speak to survivors; Livy (21.34) tells the same story - the friendly-seeming envoys, the hostages, the strong rear guard, the attack in a narrow pass - which supports it, although Livy probably used Polybius; 'just as we Greeks use the herald's staff' shows that Polybius was explaining to Greek readers; it does not distort the facts; Hannibal's private reasoning ('he reasoned that if he accepted ...') could not be known exactly; Polybius infers it, perhaps from what happened; 'would have been utterly destroyed' is Polybius' own dramatic judgement; it stresses Hannibal's foresight, and Polybius admired Hannibal as a rational, careful general (he attacks writers who said gods guided him); he gives no place names or numbers, so we cannot check the details; the exact route over the Alps is still disputed.

Question 4

20 marks

'Hannibal's crossing of the Alps was a costly mistake.'

How far do you agree with this view?

You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.

Model answer

The crossing of the Alps cost Hannibal dearly, but it was not a mistake, because it was the only way to fight the war in Italy and it gave him the surprise that led to his greatest victories.

The cost is clear from the sources. Polybius says Hannibal left the Rhone with 38,000 infantry and over 8,000 cavalry, but reached the Po valley with only 20,000 infantry and 6,000 cavalry. The second figure is strong evidence, because Polybius says it comes from the inscription Hannibal himself set up at Lacinium. The march was full of disasters: the attack by the Allobroges, the ambush by the tribe that pretended friendship, the snow and the landslide on the descent. Polybius, who says he questioned survivors and crossed the Alps himself, describes animals falling over cliffs and elephants starving. Livy paints an even darker picture of an army terrified by the snowy peaks and the 'wild and unkempt' mountain people, though his dramatic style, written for Roman readers two centuries later, may exaggerate. The march also cut Hannibal off from Iberia: his brother Hasdrubal only followed him in 207 BC and was destroyed at the Metaurus.

However, there was no real alternative. Rome controlled the sea after the First Punic War, and Polybius says the Romans expected to fight in Iberia, not Italy. Livy shows how the consul Publius Scipio arrived at the Rhone three days too late and decided to wait for Hannibal in Italy instead. By the time Rome reacted, Hannibal was in the Po valley, where the Gauls joined him. Polybius stresses that this was planned: Hannibal had found out about the Gauls' hatred of Rome and secured guides such as Magilus. Polybius admired Hannibal's rational planning, and he attacked writers who claimed gods had guided him, so he may emphasise preparation, but the arrival of the Gallic chiefs at the Rhone supports him.

The results also justify the crossing. Within weeks Hannibal defeated the Romans at the Ticinus and the Trebia, and later at Trasimene and Cannae. The crossing also undermined Rome's plans: Polybius notes that the Senate had expected a long war fought in Iberia, with Saguntum as a base, and had sent the consul Sempronius to Sicily to prepare an invasion of Africa; he had to be recalled in haste to defend northern Italy. The ordeal also bound the army to its general: at the summit he showed them Italy and 'where Rome itself lay', and they followed him for fifteen years.

In conclusion, the crossing was extremely costly, as Polybius' figures prove, but given Rome's command of the sea it was the only way to strike at Italy, and it achieved surprise and Gallic support. The real mistake was not the crossing but Hannibal's later failure to build a secure link with Iberia.

Explanation

A top answer uses Polybius' figures and both writers' accounts of the dangers, judges how far each can be trusted (Polybius' journey and use of Hannibal's inscription, Livy's dramatic style), and weighs the cost against the strategic gains. Answers that only tell the story of the crossing, or never discuss reliability, are capped.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks: AO3 10, AO1 5, AO2 5).
    Level 5 (17-20 marks): Detailed evaluation of the ancient sources in their historical context, with thorough analysis of their reliability and accuracy in terms of the context in which they were created, used to make developed, supported judgements and fully convincing conclusions (AO3). A range of detailed, accurate knowledge and a developed understanding (AO1). Thorough, convincing analysis with substantiated, developed judgements (AO2). A sustained, coherent and logically structured line of reasoning.
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): Detailed evaluation of the ancient sources in their context, with some analysis of their reliability and accuracy, used to make supported judgements and reasonable conclusions (AO3). Accurate knowledge and a developed understanding (AO1). A full analysis; judgements are substantiated but not consistently well developed (AO2). A clear, logically structured line of reasoning.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): Analyses examples from the ancient sources, with a basic analysis of the reliability and accuracy of at least one source in terms of its context, used to make basic judgements and simple conclusions (AO3). Accurate knowledge and some understanding (AO1). Analysis and explanation; judgements may not be explicit (AO2). A mostly relevant line of reasoning with some structure.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): Uses examples from the ancient sources, with a very basic attempt to consider a source's reliability or accuracy that may border on assertion; no source analysis is used to reach judgements (AO3). Basic knowledge and some understanding (AO1). A basic explanation (AO2). Some relevance; limited structure.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): Basic use of the sources, with no attempt to consider their reliability or accuracy (AO3). Basic knowledge (AO1). Little or no explanation, close to assertion (AO2). Basic, unstructured communication.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 8 if the answer makes no use of the ancient sources (it never names, quotes or discusses any ancient writer, work, inscription, coin or other object, and knowing the events is not using the sources). Max 8 if the answer never considers how reliable or accurate any ancient source is. Max 12 if the answer considers only one side of the statement and never addresses the other (the issue of extent).
    No set answer is expected. It is possible to reach the highest mark either by agreeing or disagreeing with the statement (providing the issue of extent is addressed by refuting the counter-argument), or anywhere between. To access Level 3 and above, answers discuss the ancient sources; at lower levels they may only retell stories from the sources or name them. Candidates do not have to quote directly or give precise references.
    Grounds for agreeing include: huge losses: Polybius says he left the Rhone with 38,000 infantry and over 8,000 cavalry and lost about half (3.60); he reached Italy with 20,000 infantry and 6,000 cavalry (3.56, recorded on Hannibal's own inscription); many horses, pack animals and supplies lost; the survivors were exhausted and starving (Polybius 3.51-56; Livy 21.33-35); the elephants suffered badly (Polybius 3.55) and almost all died soon after the Trebia; the march cut Hannibal off from Iberia: reinforcements by land took years (Hasdrubal only in 207 BC); he arrived too weak to besiege cities and had to rely on fickle Gallic allies.
    Grounds for disagreeing include: Rome controlled the sea, so the Alps were the only practical route; the Romans expected to fight in Iberia and Africa and were taken by surprise (Polybius 3.15-16); Scipio missed him at the Rhone (Livy 21.32) and Hannibal reached the Po valley before Rome could stop him; the Gauls of the Po valley joined him, replacing his losses (Polybius 3.34, 3.44); victories at the Ticinus and Trebia (218 BC) followed within weeks, then Trasimene and Cannae; the crossing showed his leadership and built his army's confidence (speeches, Polybius 3.54; Livy 21.35).
    Likely sources to be included: Polybius, The Histories 3.50-3.56 (the Allobroges, the ambush, the summit, the descent, the numbers); Livy 21.32-21.35 (the approach, the ambushes, the view of Italy); Polybius 3.34 and 3.44 (planning; the Gallic chiefs); Livy 21.26-21.29 (the Rhone).
    The source analysis is likely to address: Polybius crossed the Alps himself and questioned survivors (3.48); his figures for the army that reached Italy come from Hannibal's own inscription at Lacinium (3.56), so the losses are well attested; Polybius admired Hannibal's rational planning and attacked writers who invented divine help, so he stresses careful preparation; Livy's descriptions are dramatic and emotional (the soldiers' terror at the snowy peaks and the 'wild and unkempt' mountain people, Livy 21.32; the speech at the summit), written for Roman readers under Augustus, and may exaggerate the horrors; both writers knew Hannibal eventually lost, which may colour their view of the cost.
    Reductive comments ('Livy is Roman so biased', 'Polybius was not there') are basic analysis on their own.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.