'Numa was the most successful of Rome's kings.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
Numa has a strong claim to be Rome's most successful king if success means lasting peace and institutions. But if success means making Rome larger and more powerful, several other kings, especially Servius Tullius, achieved more.
The case for Numa is strong. He reigned for forty-three years without a single war. Livy says he won over 'all his neighbours by alliances and treaties' and closed the temple of Janus, something done only twice in the next seven centuries. His aim was to refound a city 'founded by force and arms' on 'justice, laws and good customs'. His religious reforms lasted for centuries. He reorganised the calendar into twelve months, appointed the flamens of Jupiter, Mars and Quirinus, chose the Vestal Virgins and the Salii, and put all religion under the pontifex. Livy says that respect for promises and oaths, rather than fear of laws and punishments, governed the state, and that neighbours thought it wrong to attack such a pious city. Unlike most kings, he died peacefully, with no scandal or crime attached to his name, and his grandson Ancus was praised for reviving his rites.
However, Numa's success had limits. He added no territory and did nothing to strengthen the army. Livy says Tullus Hostilius thought the state was 'growing idle' in peace, and in fact Rome's later wars had to be fought by his successors. By that measure, other kings did more. Romulus founded the city and created its Senate and assemblies. Tullus doubled the citizen body by absorbing Alba Longa, and Ancus reached the sea at Ostia and built the first bridge across the Tiber.
The Etruscan kings changed Rome even more. Tarquinius Priscus drained the Forum and laid out the Circus Maximus, and Servius Tullius' census and five classes reorganised the army and the voting system in a way that lasted into the Republic; he also enlarged the city and built a wall. Even Tarquinius Superbus, a tyrant, made Rome the head of the Latin League and built the great temple on the Capitol.
The evidence also needs care. Livy says Numa 'pretended' to meet Egeria, so his success may have depended on deception. Much of his story is probably legend, attaching Rome's ancient priesthoods to a single wise founder, while archaeology gives clearer evidence for the building works of the Etruscan kings.
In conclusion, Numa was the most successful king in creating peace and lasting religious institutions, and he was the most admired by the Roman writers. But Servius Tullius was arguably more successful overall, because his reforms shaped Rome's army and politics for centuries and his reign also brought growth. So I only partly agree with the statement.
Explanation
Top answers define 'successful' and compare Numa with several kings from both eras (Romulus, Tullus, Ancus, Priscus, Servius, even Superbus), balancing his peace and lasting religion against his lack of military or territorial growth. Pointing out that his story is largely legend is credited. A description of Numa's reign alone is capped.