'The gods, not human beings, decided Rome's fate from its foundation to the end of the monarchy.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
The ancient accounts of early Rome are full of gods, omens and miracles, and the Romans clearly believed their city was destined for greatness. However, when the stories are examined closely, human decisions explain most of what happened, and the ancient writers often admit this themselves.
There is much to support the statement. Livy says the origin of Rome 'was owed to the Fates'. Aeneas, son of Venus, was guided to Italy by fate, and Romulus and Remus were said to be sons of Mars, saved by a flood and a she-wolf. The gods chose the founder by augury, when Romulus saw twelve vultures to Remus' six. Romulus' prayer to Jupiter Stator was said to have halted the Roman rout against the Sabines, and at the end of his life he was taken up to heaven. Under Numa, religion shaped the state, and Tullus Hostilius was killed by Jupiter's lightning for performing a rite wrongly. The gods were also involved in the Etruscan era. An eagle lifted and replaced Tarquinius Priscus' cap as a sign that he would rule, flames appeared round the young Servius Tullius' head, and when the Capitoline temple was begun, Terminus refused to move and a human head was found, both read as signs of Rome's future greatness. Even the end of the monarchy was linked to the Delphic oracle and Brutus kissing 'his mother', the earth.
However, people make the key decisions in nearly every story. Amulius seized power, and the twins planned his killing. Romulus built the state through human policies: the asylum, the Senate of a hundred 'fathers', laws and twelve lictors. He won wars against Caenina, Fidenae and Veii, and it was the Sabine women, not the gods, who ended the Sabine war. Tullus destroyed Alba Longa and doubled Rome's citizens, and Ancus built the first bridge and founded Ostia. In the Etruscan era power was won by human skill and crime: Priscus used wealth, generosity and the first election campaign; Tanaquil hid her husband's death so that Servius could take over; and Tarquinius Superbus seized the throne by violence with Tullia's help. The monarchy fell because of Superbus' tyranny and his son's crime against Lucretia, and because Brutus roused the people.
The ancient writers also explain away many divine elements. Livy suggests Rhea Silvia named Mars because 'a god was a more respectable person to blame'. He says the 'she-wolf' may have been Larentia, and that Numa 'pretended' to meet Egeria to make a warlike people fear the gods. He even reports the rumour that the senators killed Romulus. Omens were often interpreted by interested people, such as Tanaquil, an expert in Etruscan prophecy, who used them to promote her husband and Servius. These stories may have been created later to make the result look destined.
In conclusion, the statement is true of how the Romans told their history, because the gods give the story its sense of destiny. But the actual causes of change, such as new institutions, wars, wealth, murder and rebellion, are human in both eras. The divine elements are best seen as later explanations of events that people brought about.
Explanation
High marks need a balanced argument across both eras (for example augury, Mars and Romulus' deification against Priscus' canvassing, Tanaquil's plan and Superbus' crimes) with a clear final judgement. Recognising that the sources themselves often rationalise the divine stories earns credit under AO2. Answers that only list omens, or that stay with the foundation myths alone, are capped.