'Hannibal went to war with Rome mainly to keep the oath he swore to his father.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
The oath shows that Hannibal's hostility to Rome began in childhood, but the sources suggest that he went to war for a wider mix of reasons, so I largely disagree that it was the main motive.
The case for the oath comes mainly from Polybius. He tells how Hamilcar, before leaving for Iberia, led the nine-year-old Hannibal to the altar and made him swear never to be a friend of the Romans. Polybius calls this 'unquestionable proof' of Hamilcar's hostility and says that Hamilcar made Hannibal and Hasdrubal the bitterest enemies of Rome. When Hannibal met the Roman envoys in the winter of 220-219 BC, Polybius says he was 'driven on by his long-standing hatred of Rome'. Hannibal's whole career, from Saguntum to his exile at Antiochus' court, fits a lifelong vow, and Livy's description of him leaving Italy in 203 BC, wishing he had marched on Rome, shows how personal the war was to him.
However, the oath story needs careful handling. Polybius says Hannibal told it years later to King Antiochus, who suspected him of being friendly with Rome. It was therefore told to win trust and may have been exaggerated. Polybius probably heard it at second hand, and he uses it to support his own theory about Hamilcar's anger.
Moreover, Polybius himself gives other causes. He calls the seizure of Sardinia and the extra payment the 'second and main cause', and Carthage's success in Iberia the third, because it gave the Carthaginians confidence. His account of the meeting with the envoys also stresses that Hannibal was young, confident after his victories and angry, and that he used Saguntum as an excuse. Roman interference at Saguntum, which Polybius says the Romans expected to use as a base, gave Hannibal a strategic reason to strike first. Fabius Pictor, a Roman senator, blamed the ambition and love of power of the Barcids instead, but he wanted to make Rome's war look just, and Polybius rejects his view because Carthage refused to hand Hannibal over and its senators shouted 'We accept it'. Hannibal's careful planning also suggests calculation rather than a simple vow. Polybius says that before he marched he had found out about the fertile land of the Po valley and the Gauls' hatred of Rome, and sent envoys with great promises to their chiefs, because he saw that he could only fight in Italy with their help. Livy, writing under Augustus, even tells of a dream at the Ebro in which a divine guide led Hannibal to Italy, presenting the invasion as destiny rather than revenge, although Livy introduces it as a story and it tells us more about Roman ideas of fate than about Hannibal's real thoughts.
In conclusion, the oath helps to explain Hannibal's hostility, but he went to war because of a combination of inherited hatred, Carthaginian grievances over Sardinia, the strength Carthage had gained in Iberia and the threat that Rome would use Saguntum against it. The oath was a symbol of these motives rather than the main one.
Explanation
A top answer uses Polybius' account of the oath and of Hannibal's meeting with the Roman envoys, evaluates the oath story (told by Hannibal himself, years later, to persuade Antiochus) and weighs it against the other causes the sources give. Answers that simply retell the oath, or ignore the reliability of the story, cannot reach the top levels.