Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
OCR GCSE Ancient History (Rome and its neighbours) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
The foundations of Rome: from kingship to republic, 753-440 BC (longer period study)
Unit 2
Hannibal and the Second Punic War, 218-201 BC (depth study)
Unit 3
Cleopatra: Rome and Egypt, 69-30 BC (depth study)
Unit 4
Britannia: from conquest to province, AD 43-c.84 (depth study)
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/45

The war party at Carthage and Hannibal's motives

Practise 12 exam-style questions on The war party at Carthage and Hannibal's motives for OCR GCSE Ancient History (Rome and its neighbours). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 12 questions
  • 1–20 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
12 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

Give two details of the story of Hannibal's oath, as Polybius tells it.

Model answer

Hannibal was nine years old when his father Hamilcar, sacrificing before leaving for Iberia, led him to the altar and made him swear, with his hand on the victim, never to be a friend of the Romans.

Explanation

Polybius (3.11) says that Hannibal himself told this story to King Antiochus, years after the war, to prove that he would always be Rome's enemy. Typical correct details are his age (nine), the sacrifice, the altar, the hand on the victim and the promise never to be Rome's friend. 'Swore to destroy Rome' is a popular exaggeration that the sources do not support.

Mark scheme
  1. 2 marks

    Any two of: Hannibal was nine years old; Hamilcar was sacrificing (to Zeus) before setting out with his army for Iberia; Hannibal begged / was delighted to go with his father on the expedition; Hamilcar sent the others away and asked him if he wanted to come; Hamilcar led him to the altar; Hannibal laid his hand on the sacrificial victim; he swore never to be a friend of the Romans; Hannibal told the story many years later to King Antiochus (to prove he was an enemy of Rome)

    1 mark for each different correct answer, max 2. Allow recognisable spellings. Credit Livy's wording of the oath (to be an enemy of Rome as soon as he could). Credit any other detail found in Polybius 3.11.
    Do not credit: 'he swore to destroy Rome' or 'he swore to invade Italy' (neither source says this); details of Hannibal's dream at the Ebro (a different story, in Livy 21.22).

Question 2

5 marks

Passage B

Polybius reports the view of Fabius Pictor, a Roman senator who wrote a history of the war.

'Fabius, the Roman historian, says that besides the wrong done to the Saguntines, a cause of the war was the ambition and love of power of Hasdrubal. He tells us that after Hasdrubal had won a great empire in Iberia, he came to Africa and tried to overthrow the constitution of Carthage and turn it into a monarchy. But the leading statesmen found out his plan and united to oppose him. Hasdrubal, suspecting their intentions, left Africa and from then on governed Iberia as he pleased, paying no attention to the Carthaginian senate. Hannibal had shared and admired Hasdrubal's policy from boyhood, and when he took over the command in Iberia he followed the same course. So, Fabius says, Hannibal began this war against Rome on his own initiative and against the wishes of the Carthaginians, since not one of the notable men in Carthage approved of what he did to Saguntum.'

Polybius, The Histories 3.8.1-7 (adapted)

What can we learn from Passage B about attitudes in Carthage towards war with Rome?

Model answer

The passage suggests that Carthage was divided over war. Fabius Pictor blames 'the ambition and love of power of Hasdrubal', and claims that Hasdrubal 'tried to overthrow the constitution', so some Carthaginians feared that the Barcid generals in Iberia were becoming too powerful. 'The leading statesmen ... united to oppose him', which shows strong opposition among the elite, and Hasdrubal then 'governed Iberia as he pleased', ignoring the senate, so the war party's strength lay with the army in Iberia. Hannibal 'shared and admired' this policy, and Fabius says he began the war 'on his own initiative', with 'not one of the notable men' approving. We can therefore learn that, in this Roman's view, the war was driven by the Barcid family against the wishes of Carthage's leaders, although we should remember that Polybius, who reports this, rejected it.

Explanation

Good answers explain what each detail suggests about Carthaginian opinion: suspicion of the Barcids, the independence of Iberia and the claim that the nobles disapproved. The strongest answers also notice that this is Fabius Pictor's opinion reported by Polybius, not a neutral account.

Mark scheme
  1. 5 marks

    Levels of response (5 marks, AO3).
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): Response uses a range of fully appropriate details from the passage, which are analysed to draw out relevant characteristics and features and give a detailed and sophisticated evaluation of what we can learn from the source about the specified issue in the question.
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): Response uses some appropriate details from the passage, which are analysed to draw out some of the characteristics and features and evaluate what we can learn from the source about the specified issue in the question.
    Level 1 (1 mark): Response uses few details from the passage and makes a very basic attempt to draw out any of the characteristics and features in relation to the question.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 1 if the answer makes no use of the passage (own knowledge alone does not answer this question).
    Details must be explained, not just copied: credit what each detail tells us about the issue. A Level 3 answer explains a range of details from across the passage; a Level 1 answer only picks out or copies a detail or two. Own knowledge may be used to explain a detail but is not required.
    Candidates are likely to pick out and explain: 'the wrong done to the Saguntines': the attack on Saguntum, Rome's friend, is seen as the immediate cause of the war; 'the ambition and love of power of Hasdrubal': the Barcid commanders are accused of serving their own power rather than Carthage; 'tried to overthrow the constitution of Carthage and turn it into a monarchy': there was fear in Carthage that the generals in Iberia were becoming too powerful; 'the leading statesmen ... united to oppose him': there was strong opposition to the Barcids among the Carthaginian elite (the faction of Hanno); 'governed Iberia as he pleased, paying no attention to the Carthaginian senate': the war party's power base was the army in Iberia, not the senate; 'Hannibal had shared and admired Hasdrubal's policy from boyhood': the attitude was handed down within the family; 'on his own initiative and against the wishes of the Carthaginians': Fabius presents the war as Hannibal's, not Carthage's - the war party was a minority; 'not one of the notable men in Carthage approved': the nobles are said to have opposed the attack on Saguntum.
    Credit answers that point out that this is Fabius Pictor's view, reported (and later rejected) by Polybius, so it tells us what one Roman thought about Carthaginian attitudes.

Question 3

5 marks

Passage B

In 218 BC, after Hannibal has captured Saguntum, Rome sends an embassy to Carthage.

'When the Romans heard of the disaster that had happened to Saguntum, they at once chose ambassadors and sent them in haste to Carthage. They offered the Carthaginians two choices: one, if they accepted it, would bring them disgrace and harm; the other would lead to great trouble and danger. Either they must hand over Hannibal and the members of his council, or war would be declared. When the envoys arrived and gave their message to the senate, the Carthaginians listened to this choice with anger ... [After the Carthaginians had put their case,] the oldest of the envoys pointed to the fold of his toga and told the senate that it held both war and peace for them: he would let fall from it whichever of the two they told him to. The Carthaginian suffete [chief magistrate] told him to let fall whichever the Romans chose. When the envoy said that he let fall war, many of the senators shouted out at once, 'We accept it!''

Polybius, The Histories 3.20.6-9 and 3.33.1-4 (adapted)

Using details from Passage B, how accurate do you think Polybius' account of the Roman embassy to Carthage is?

Model answer

Polybius' account is probably accurate in its main points but dramatised in its details. Writing about seventy years later, he knew members of the Scipios' circle and had read Fabius Pictor, so a famous embassy would be well known to him. The core facts, that Rome demanded that Carthage 'hand over Hannibal and the members of his council' or face war, are supported by Fabius Pictor and by Livy. However, the scene of the envoy letting fall war from 'the fold of his toga' and the senators shouting 'We accept it!' is very theatrical, and exact words are unlikely to have been recorded. Even so, Polybius usually rejects invented scenes, as when he mocks the story of the Roman Senate debate, so he must have trusted this one. He may also include the senators' shout because it supports his argument that Carthage really wanted the war. Overall, it is reliable on what happened, less so on the exact words.

Explanation

Strong answers separate the reliable core of the passage (the embassy, the demand and the declaration of war) from details that may have been dramatised (the toga, the shouted reply), and link this to what we know of Polybius' sources and methods. Generic comments about Polybius' date without reference to the passage stay low.

Mark scheme
  1. 5 marks

    Levels of response (5 marks, AO3).
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): Response analyses the source by using relevant detail from the source content or historical context to give a more detailed evaluation of the source within its historical context. It draws a thorough and convincing conclusion about its accuracy or reliability based on how the context in which it was created impacts on how it portrays issues or events.
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): Response analyses the source by using relevant detail from the source content or historical context to give a basic evaluation of the source within its historical context. It draws a basic conclusion about its accuracy or reliability based on how the context in which it was created impacts on how it portrays issues or events.
    Level 1 (1 mark): Response analyses the source in a basic way by selecting relevant detail from the source content or historical context.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 1 if the answer reaches no conclusion at all about how accurate or reliable the passage is.
    Full marks need the evaluation to be related to the particular events in the passage, not only general comments about the author. A conclusion that the passage is accurate, inaccurate or partly accurate can all reach Level 3 if it is supported. Treat bare assertions such as 'he was not there' or 'he was biased' with care: on their own they are Level 1.
    Candidates might comment on: Polybius wrote about seventy years later, but he knew Romans of the next generation (the Scipios' circle) and had read Roman writers such as Fabius Pictor; a famous embassy would be well remembered in Rome; the basic facts (an embassy, the demand to hand over Hannibal and his council, a declaration of war) are confirmed by Fabius Pictor's account (in Polybius 3.8) and by Livy's account; the dramatic toga scene and 'We accept it!' are vivid and memorable; stories like this can be polished in retelling, and the exact words are unlikely to have been recorded; Polybius rejects dramatic invented scenes elsewhere: he mocks Chaereas and Sosylus for an imaginary Senate debate (3.20.1-5), so including this suggests he thought it well attested; 'two choices ... disgrace and harm ... great trouble and danger' is Polybius' own analysis rather than a report; the shout of 'many of the senators' fits Polybius' argument against Fabius Pictor that Carthage supported the war - he may have chosen the detail for that reason; Polybius was pro-Roman, but he presents Carthage's case fairly, giving the Carthaginian legal arguments in his next chapter (3.21).

Question 4

20 marks

'Hannibal went to war with Rome mainly to keep the oath he swore to his father.'

How far do you agree with this view?

You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.

Model answer

The oath shows that Hannibal's hostility to Rome began in childhood, but the sources suggest that he went to war for a wider mix of reasons, so I largely disagree that it was the main motive.

The case for the oath comes mainly from Polybius. He tells how Hamilcar, before leaving for Iberia, led the nine-year-old Hannibal to the altar and made him swear never to be a friend of the Romans. Polybius calls this 'unquestionable proof' of Hamilcar's hostility and says that Hamilcar made Hannibal and Hasdrubal the bitterest enemies of Rome. When Hannibal met the Roman envoys in the winter of 220-219 BC, Polybius says he was 'driven on by his long-standing hatred of Rome'. Hannibal's whole career, from Saguntum to his exile at Antiochus' court, fits a lifelong vow, and Livy's description of him leaving Italy in 203 BC, wishing he had marched on Rome, shows how personal the war was to him.

However, the oath story needs careful handling. Polybius says Hannibal told it years later to King Antiochus, who suspected him of being friendly with Rome. It was therefore told to win trust and may have been exaggerated. Polybius probably heard it at second hand, and he uses it to support his own theory about Hamilcar's anger.

Moreover, Polybius himself gives other causes. He calls the seizure of Sardinia and the extra payment the 'second and main cause', and Carthage's success in Iberia the third, because it gave the Carthaginians confidence. His account of the meeting with the envoys also stresses that Hannibal was young, confident after his victories and angry, and that he used Saguntum as an excuse. Roman interference at Saguntum, which Polybius says the Romans expected to use as a base, gave Hannibal a strategic reason to strike first. Fabius Pictor, a Roman senator, blamed the ambition and love of power of the Barcids instead, but he wanted to make Rome's war look just, and Polybius rejects his view because Carthage refused to hand Hannibal over and its senators shouted 'We accept it'. Hannibal's careful planning also suggests calculation rather than a simple vow. Polybius says that before he marched he had found out about the fertile land of the Po valley and the Gauls' hatred of Rome, and sent envoys with great promises to their chiefs, because he saw that he could only fight in Italy with their help. Livy, writing under Augustus, even tells of a dream at the Ebro in which a divine guide led Hannibal to Italy, presenting the invasion as destiny rather than revenge, although Livy introduces it as a story and it tells us more about Roman ideas of fate than about Hannibal's real thoughts.

In conclusion, the oath helps to explain Hannibal's hostility, but he went to war because of a combination of inherited hatred, Carthaginian grievances over Sardinia, the strength Carthage had gained in Iberia and the threat that Rome would use Saguntum against it. The oath was a symbol of these motives rather than the main one.

Explanation

A top answer uses Polybius' account of the oath and of Hannibal's meeting with the Roman envoys, evaluates the oath story (told by Hannibal himself, years later, to persuade Antiochus) and weighs it against the other causes the sources give. Answers that simply retell the oath, or ignore the reliability of the story, cannot reach the top levels.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks: AO3 10, AO1 5, AO2 5).
    Level 5 (17-20 marks): Detailed evaluation of the ancient sources in their historical context, with thorough analysis of their reliability and accuracy in terms of the context in which they were created, used to make developed, supported judgements and fully convincing conclusions (AO3). A range of detailed, accurate knowledge and a developed understanding (AO1). Thorough, convincing analysis with substantiated, developed judgements (AO2). A sustained, coherent and logically structured line of reasoning.
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): Detailed evaluation of the ancient sources in their context, with some analysis of their reliability and accuracy, used to make supported judgements and reasonable conclusions (AO3). Accurate knowledge and a developed understanding (AO1). A full analysis; judgements are substantiated but not consistently well developed (AO2). A clear, logically structured line of reasoning.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): Analyses examples from the ancient sources, with a basic analysis of the reliability and accuracy of at least one source in terms of its context, used to make basic judgements and simple conclusions (AO3). Accurate knowledge and some understanding (AO1). Analysis and explanation; judgements may not be explicit (AO2). A mostly relevant line of reasoning with some structure.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): Uses examples from the ancient sources, with a very basic attempt to consider a source's reliability or accuracy that may border on assertion; no source analysis is used to reach judgements (AO3). Basic knowledge and some understanding (AO1). A basic explanation (AO2). Some relevance; limited structure.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): Basic use of the sources, with no attempt to consider their reliability or accuracy (AO3). Basic knowledge (AO1). Little or no explanation, close to assertion (AO2). Basic, unstructured communication.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 8 if the answer makes no use of the ancient sources (it never names, quotes or discusses any ancient writer, work, inscription, coin or other object, and knowing the events is not using the sources). Max 8 if the answer never considers how reliable or accurate any ancient source is. Max 12 if the answer considers only one side of the statement and never addresses the other (the issue of extent).
    No set answer is expected. It is possible to reach the highest mark either by agreeing or disagreeing with the statement (providing the issue of extent is addressed by refuting the counter-argument), or anywhere between. To access Level 3 and above, answers discuss the ancient sources; at lower levels they may only retell stories from the sources or name them. Candidates do not have to quote directly or give precise references.
    Grounds for agreeing include: Polybius tells the oath story (3.11) and calls it unquestionable proof of Hamilcar's hostility, saying Hamilcar made Hannibal and Hasdrubal bitter enemies of Rome (3.12); Polybius describes Hannibal as driven by 'long-standing hatred of Rome' when he met the Roman envoys (3.15); Hannibal fought Rome all his life, even after Zama (at Antiochus' court), consistent with a personal vow; Livy 30.20 shows his bitterness at leaving Italy, wishing he had marched on Rome after Cannae.
    Grounds for disagreeing include: Polybius himself gives three causes: Hamilcar's anger, the seizure of Sardinia (the main cause) and success in Iberia (3.9-10); the oath only illustrates the first; Polybius 3.15 stresses Hannibal's youth, confidence and anger, and the dispute over Saguntum; the threat of Roman expansion into Iberia and Saguntum as a possible Roman base (Polybius 3.15); Fabius Pictor (Polybius 3.8) blames Barcid ambition and love of power; Carthage itself accepted war ('We accept it', Polybius 3.33); Hannibal planned to win over the Gauls (Polybius 3.34) - a strategic decision, not just a vow; Livy 21.22's dream presents the invasion as divinely guided destiny.
    Likely sources to be included: Polybius, The Histories 3.9-3.12 (causes; the oath); Polybius 3.15 (Hannibal and the Roman envoys); Polybius 3.8 (Fabius Pictor's view); Polybius 3.33-3.34 (declaration of war; Hannibal's plans); Livy 21.22 (the dream); Livy 30.20 (Hannibal's departure).
    The source analysis is likely to address: the oath story comes from Hannibal himself, told decades later to win King Antiochus' trust, so it may be self-serving; Polybius may have heard it from people at Antiochus' court; Polybius uses the story to support his own theory that Hamilcar's anger was a cause, and he admits it is an anecdote; Polybius' judgement on Hannibal's 'violent anger' is his own interpretation; Fabius Pictor was a Roman senator who blamed individuals to make Rome's war look just; Livy's dream and his speech in 30.20 are literary and dramatic, written under Augustus.
    Reductive comments ('Livy is Roman so biased', 'Polybius was not there') are basic analysis on their own.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.