Passage C
Caesar has arrived in Alexandria and has reconciled Cleopatra and her brother, Ptolemy XIII, on terms of shared rule.
'Then, while everyone was feasting to celebrate the reconciliation, Caesar's barber, a slave whose timidity made him look into everything, discovered that Achillas the general and Pothinus the eunuch were plotting against Caesar. Caesar set a guard round the banqueting hall and put Pothinus to death. But Achillas escaped to his camp and stirred up a difficult and dangerous war against Caesar, who had very few men to defend himself against so large a city and army. In this war Caesar was first in danger of being cut off from water, since the enemy blocked the canals; then, when they tried to cut off his fleet, he was forced to drive them back with fire, which spread from the dockyards and destroyed the great library ... Finally, after the king had gone over to the enemy, Caesar marched against him and defeated him in a battle in which many fell and the king himself disappeared. Then, leaving Cleopatra as ruler of Egypt, Caesar set out for Syria.'
Plutarch, Life of Caesar 49 (adapted)
What can we learn from Passage C about the war between Cleopatra and Ptolemy XIII?
Model answer
Passage C shows that the war between Cleopatra and Ptolemy XIII was really fought by Caesar on her behalf. The 'reconciliation' that Caesar arranged did not last, because 'Achillas the general and Pothinus the eunuch' plotted against him, which suggests the young king's advisers, not the boy himself, led the opposition to Cleopatra. Ptolemy's side was strong: Caesar had 'very few men' against 'so large a city and army', so Cleopatra's supporters were in a minority in Alexandria. The fighting was dangerous and destructive, with the water supply cut and fire spreading to 'the great library'. When 'the king had gone over to the enemy', the war became open battle, and it ended when 'the king himself disappeared'. Caesar then left 'Cleopatra as ruler of Egypt', so her victory depended entirely on Roman force.
Explanation
Top answers explain what the details show: who led the opposition, how strong Ptolemy's side was, how destructive the war was, and how it ended with Cleopatra restored by Caesar. Listing events from the passage without explaining them is Level 1. Own knowledge (for example that Ptolemy drowned in the Nile) can support but not replace use of the passage.