'Cleopatra gained more than Caesar from their relationship.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Cleopatra gained far more than Caesar from their relationship, because it turned her from an exile into the secure ruler of Egypt, while for Caesar the gains were real but limited and came at a high cost.
Cleopatra's gains were enormous. In 48 BC she had been driven out by her brother's advisers. Plutarch's Life of Caesar shows that Caesar destroyed her enemies, killing Pothinus and defeating Ptolemy XIII, and then left 'Cleopatra as ruler of Egypt'. Dio says Caesar gave Egypt to her, and that although she had to 'marry' her younger brother, she held all the power, since with Caesar's favour 'there was nothing she could not do'. Egypt stayed independent, Cyprus was restored, and Roman legions protected her. In Rome, Dio says, Caesar enrolled her among the friends and allies of the Roman people, and Suetonius says he loaded her with 'great honours and rich gifts' and let her give his name to her son. She used Caesarion to strengthen her rule, as the Cyprus coin and the Dendera relief show.
Caesar also gained. Plutarch says Ptolemy XII had owed him seventeen and a half million drachmas and that he demanded ten million for his army, so Egypt's wealth helped to fund his wars. He secured a loyal ally in Egypt, closing it to his Pompeian enemies, without having to make it a province that a rival might govern. Suetonius also suggests personal pleasure, with feasting and a journey up the Nile.
But the relationship cost Caesar a great deal. The war in Alexandria nearly killed him, and Plutarch notes that 'some say' it was unnecessary and caused by passion. Dio says Cleopatra delayed him in Egypt until Pharnaces' revolt dragged him away, and in Rome her visit brought him 'the greatest censure'. Cicero's bitter comments show the hostility she caused, which fed fears that Caesar wanted to be a king.
The sources need care. Plutarch's Life of Caesar focuses on Caesar and how he was 'captivated', and Suetonius enjoys gossip about Caesar's love life, although he weighs his sources. Dio, writing about 250 years later, presents Caesar as moved by fear and passion. Cicero's letter is contemporary but personally hostile, while the coin and relief are Cleopatra's own propaganda, showing what she wanted to gain.
Overall, Cleopatra gained more: her throne, independence and an heir with Caesar's name. However, her gains depended on one man, and after his murder in 44 BC she lost her protector and Caesarion was left out of his will. So she gained more, but her gains were less secure than they seemed.
Explanation
High-level answers compare gains (and costs) on both sides with specific evidence from Plutarch, Dio, Suetonius and Cicero, analyse those sources' viewpoints, and reach a balanced judgement. Answers that only describe what Cleopatra gained, without considering Caesar, are capped at 12.