'Courage was the most important part of Cleopatra's character.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
The ancient sources do give great weight to Cleopatra's courage, especially in her death, but they stress her charm and intelligence more often, so courage was not the most important part of her character.
The case for courage is strongest at the end of her life. Horace's ode, written in 30 BC to celebrate Octavian's victory, suddenly praises her: she 'did not fear the sword as women do', looked on her fallen palace 'with a calm face' and handled the snakes deliberately. Velleius Paterculus agrees that she died 'untouched by a woman's fears'. Plutarch shows her trying to stab herself when Proculeius captured her, and dying 'arrayed in royal state', with Charmion saying the death was fitting for 'the descendant of so many kings'. Courage appears earlier too: she risked her life to reach Caesar in the bed-sack, insisted on going to war in person, and planned to haul her fleet across to the Red Sea.
However, the reliability of these sources must be considered. Horace and Velleius wrote for Augustus and Tiberius. Praising Cleopatra's bravery made her a worthy enemy and Octavian's victory greater, so their admiration has a purpose. Plutarch's detailed account of her death draws partly on Olympus, her own doctor, which makes it more credible, but even he admits that 'the truth of the matter no one knows' about how she died.
The case against is strong. Plutarch, our fullest source, stresses her charm above all: her company had 'an irresistible hold' and her conversation won Antony at Tarsus. Caesar too was 'captivated'. Her wit appears in the fishing trick and the 'ladle' joke. Several sources also show actions that were not courageous: Velleius says she 'took the initiative in the flight' at Actium, and Plutarch says she hid in her tomb and sent word that she was dead. Virgil's shield shows her at Actium shaking her rattle among the fighting, then setting sail, 'pale with coming death', which suggests fear rather than courage, although Virgil, writing for Augustus, had every reason to show her running away. Her suicide can also be read as a calculation, to avoid being paraded in Octavian's triumph, rather than simple courage. Plutarch also shows her cunning: she pretended to waste away for love of Antony and deceived Octavian into thinking she wanted to live.
Overall, courage was a real and important part of Cleopatra's character, especially at her death, and even hostile Roman writers admit it. But the sources show it as one quality among several, and they explain her successes mainly by her charm and intelligence. Courage was therefore important, but not the most important part of her character.
Explanation
Level 5 answers weigh courage against other qualities with evidence from several set sources and analyse those sources: why Augustan writers might praise an enemy's courage, and how far Plutarch's sources for her death can be trusted. Answers that list brave deeds without considering the sources' purposes, or that ignore the other side, are capped.