Passage A
At the start of Book 2, Livy looks back on the rule of the kings before describing the Republic.
'The arrogance of the last king had made liberty all the more welcome. For the earlier kings ruled in such a way that all of them in turn can fairly be counted as founders of at least parts of the city, which they added as new homes for the people whose numbers they had increased. There is no doubt that the same Brutus who won such glory by driving out the proud king would have done the state great harm if, from a desire for liberty that came too early, he had taken the kingdom from any of the earlier kings. For what would have happened if that crowd of shepherds and refugees... had been freed from fear of a king and stirred up by the storms of tribunes, before wives, children and love of the land had bound them together? ... But the calm and moderate rule of the kings nursed them until they were strong enough to bear the good fruit of liberty.'
Livy, The History of Rome 2.1.1-6 (adapted)
Using details from Passage A and your own knowledge, explain the importance of the kings in preparing Rome for the Republic.
Model answer
The passage shows that Livy believed the kings were essential preparation for the Republic. He says 'all of them in turn can fairly be counted as founders of at least parts of the city', adding 'new homes for the people whose numbers they had increased'. From own knowledge, Romulus opened an asylum to attract settlers and united with the Sabines, Tullus Hostilius brought the people of Alba Longa to Rome, and Ancus Marcius settled conquered Latins on the Aventine. The kings therefore built up a population large enough to form a state.
Livy also argues that the people needed time under firm rule. The early Romans were 'that crowd of shepherds and refugees', and if they had been 'stirred up by the storms of tribunes' too early, before 'wives, children and love of the land had bound them together', the state would have fallen apart. Instead, 'the calm and moderate rule of the kings nursed them' until they were ready for 'the good fruit of liberty'. This suggests the kings created the unity and loyalty a free state needed.
The kings also left the institutions the Republic used. Romulus created the Senate, and the patres and patrons and clients continued. Numa's priesthoods and calendar remained, with the rex sacrorum taking over the kings' own religious role. Most importantly, Servius Tullius' census and the assembly of the centuries were the means by which the first consuls were elected in 509. The consuls also kept the kings' fasces, lictors and curule chair. The Etruscan kings built the city itself: the Cloaca Maxima, the Forum and the temple of Jupiter on the Capitol, which was dedicated in the Republic's first year. Superbus' conquests also left Rome dominant in Latium, as the treaty with Carthage shows, which helped the Republic survive its first wars.
Finally, the passage says 'the arrogance of the last king had made liberty all the more welcome'. Superbus' tyranny gave the Republic a lasting fear of kingship, which shaped its rules on annual office, colleagues and appeal.
However, the kings also left problems: the division between patricians and plebeians and the power of the rich, which caused the conflicts after 509. Livy's view is also a later interpretation, shaped by his belief in steady progress.
Overall, the kings were very important: they built the city, its population and the institutions the Republic took over, and even the last king's tyranny helped to define what the Republic would be.
Explanation
Strong answers use the passage's argument (the kings as founders, the people needing time, the moderate rule of the kings, the welcome of liberty after Superbus) and develop it with own knowledge across both the legendary and Etruscan kings, including the institutions the Republic inherited, before weighing benefits against problems and reaching a judgement.