Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
AQA GCSE Design and Technology Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
Core technical principles
Unit 2
Specialist technical principles
Unit 3
Designing and making principles
Investigation, primary and secondary data
Investigation, primary and secondary data
Environmental, social and economic challenge
Environmental, social and economic challenge
Design strategies
Design strategies
Communication of design ideas
Communication of design ideas
Prototype development
Prototype development
Selection of materials and components
Selecting materials and components for prototypes
Specialist tools and equipment
Specialist tools and equipment
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/40

The work of others: companies

Practise 18 exam-style questions on The work of others: companies for AQA GCSE Design and Technology. Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 18 questions
  • 1–8 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
18 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

Apple's iMac G3 (1998) was designed by a team led by Jonathan Ive.

Give two design features that made the iMac G3 look or work differently from most personal computers of the time.

Model answer

It had a translucent, coloured plastic case, first in 'Bondi Blue', when most computers were plain beige boxes. It was also an all-in-one design, with the screen and the computer together in one rounded case with a handle.

Explanation

The iMac G3 used colour and see-through plastic to make a computer look friendly and fun, and its all-in-one design made it easy to set up at home. It was also one of the first computers with USB ports as standard and no floppy drive. A common mistake is to describe later Apple features, such as aluminium cases or touch screens.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Feature 1: any one correct feature, e.g. a translucent, coloured plastic (polycarbonate) case, first in 'Bondi Blue', instead of a plain beige or grey box / an all-in-one design with the screen and computer in one rounded case / a built-in handle so it could be carried / USB ports as standard / no floppy disk drive

    One mark for each correct feature given. The two features must be different. Do not credit 'touch screen', 'flat screen' or 'aluminium case' (the iMac G3 had a glass CRT screen in a plastic case). Do not credit vague answers such as 'modern' or 'stylish'. Accept all other valid responses.

  2. 1 mark

    Feature 2: a second, different correct feature from the list above

    max 2

Question 2

3 marks

Dyson's DC01 (1993) was a bagless vacuum cleaner that used cyclones instead of a dust bag.

Explain how cyclonic separation removes dust from the air, and why this is an advantage over a vacuum cleaner that collects dust in a bag.

Model answer

The dirty air is sucked in at high speed and spun round inside a cone-shaped cyclone. As the cone narrows the air speeds up, and the dust particles are flung outwards by centrifugal force, out of the airflow, so they hit the walls and drop into the bin while the cleaned air leaves through the centre. This is better than a bag because the pores of a bag clog with fine dust, so suction falls as the bag fills, but a cyclone has no bag to clog, so the suction stays high.

Explanation

James Dyson got the idea from an industrial cyclone that separated dust from air by spinning it, after he found that the pores of vacuum cleaner bags quickly clogged and reduced suction. Full marks need both the mechanism (spinning air, dust flung out) and the advantage (no clogging, so no loss of suction). A common mistake is to say only that it 'has no bag'.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    the dirty air is drawn in at high speed and spun round inside a cone-shaped cyclone, speeding up as the cone narrows

    Award 1 mark for each creditworthy point. A point explained in detail earns 2 marks. max 3. For 3 marks the answer must cover both how the cyclone separates the dust and the advantage over a bag.

  2. 1 mark

    the dust particles are flung outwards (by centrifugal force / their inertia carries them outwards) out of the airflow, hit the walls and fall into the bin, while the cleaned air leaves through the centre

    Accept 'centrifugal force' or 'the spinning throws the dust out' or an inertia explanation.

  3. 1 mark

    advantage: in a bagged cleaner the tiny pores of the bag clog with dust, so suction falls as the bag fills; the cyclone has no bag to clog, so suction stays high (does not drop as dust is collected)

    Also credit: no replacement bags to buy; the clear bin shows when it needs emptying. Do not credit 'it is bagless' alone without saying why this helps. Accept all other valid responses.

Question 3

4 marks

Since 2008 Apple has made the cases of its MacBook laptops as a 'unibody': each case is CNC machined from a single solid block of aluminium, instead of being assembled from many separate parts.

Give one advantage and one disadvantage of this method of manufacture.

Model answer

Advantage: the case is one solid piece rather than many parts joined together, so it is stronger and stiffer. This means it can be made thinner and lighter for the same strength, and there are fewer parts to assemble.

Disadvantage: most of the solid block is cut away as swarf, so a lot of material and energy are used for each case. The swarf has to be collected and recycled, and the long machining time makes each case expensive to produce.

Explanation

Machining a whole case from one block is a wastage process, so the strength and precision of the unibody come at the cost of removing a lot of material and long machining times. Each mark pair needs a specific point and its consequence. A common mistake is to say aluminium is heavy or that machining is inaccurate.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Advantage: a valid advantage, e.g. the one-piece case is stronger and stiffer / fewer parts to make and assemble / CNC machining is very accurate and repeatable / a seamless, high-quality appearance

    Maximum of two marks for the advantage and two for the disadvantage.

  2. 1 mark

    Advantage developed: explains why, e.g. so the case can be thinner and lighter for the same strength, and resists bending / fewer joints and fasteners, so assembly is quicker and there are fewer places to fail / parts fit with tight tolerances and no gaps / gives the product a premium look that supports a high price

    The development must match the advantage given.

  3. 1 mark

    Disadvantage: a valid disadvantage, e.g. much of the solid block is cut away as waste (swarf) / machining takes a long time, with many cutting operations for each case / needs many expensive CNC machines / the case is hard to repair, as one damaged area means the whole part must be replaced

  4. 1 mark

    Disadvantage developed: explains the effect, e.g. material and energy are wasted and the swarf must be collected and recycled / slow cycle times and high energy use raise the cost of each case / very high set-up cost / repairs are expensive

    Credit 'the aluminium swarf can be recycled' only as part of a disadvantage about waste, not as a disadvantage on its own (Apple now makes the enclosures of some products, such as the MacBook Air, from 100% recycled aluminium, which reduces but does not remove the impact). Do not credit 'aluminium is heavy' (it is a low-density metal). Accept all other valid responses.

Question 4

6 marks

Jamal is designing a kitchen timer. He is deciding whether to follow the approach of Alessi or of Braun.

Alessi: works with many outside designers and architects. Its products are often playful and expressive, such as Michael Graves's stainless steel kettle (1985), whose spout has a whistle shaped like a bird, and Alessandro Mendini's 'Anna G' corkscrew (1994), shaped like a woman whose arms rise as the screw goes into the cork.

Braun: under Dieter Rams, products followed the idea of 'less, but better', with plain forms, neutral colours such as white and grey, and only the controls the user needs, as on the T3 pocket radio (1958).

Analyse and evaluate both approaches for the design of Jamal's kitchen timer.

Model answer

Following Alessi's approach, Jamal could give the timer a playful, characterful form, perhaps an animal whose head turns to set the time, like the bird whistle on Graves's kettle or the figure of the Anna G corkscrew. This would make the timer fun, memorable and a good gift, and it would stand out from other timers, so it could sell at a higher price. However, decorative features could make it harder to see how to set the time or read the display quickly, and complex shapes with many parts would cost more to make and be harder to keep clean in a kitchen.

Following Braun's approach, the timer would have a plain form, a neutral colour and only the controls the user needs, like the plain front of the T3 radio, with just its speaker grid and tuning dial. This would make it understandable straight away and quick to use, even with messy hands, and smooth plain surfaces are easy to clean. Fewer parts also make it cheaper to manufacture and more reliable, and its timeless look would not date. On the other hand, it might look dull and not stand out in a shop.

I think Braun's approach is better for a kitchen timer, because its main job is to be set quickly and read clearly while cooking, and Rams's 'less, but better' suits that best. Jamal could still add a little Alessi-style character, such as a bright colour or a friendly shape, as long as it does not make the timer harder to use.

Explanation

Level 3 needs analysis of both approaches applied to the kitchen timer, with strengths and weaknesses and a justified judgement. The best answers link each company's approach to the timer's function, use, cleaning and manufacture, rather than just describing the companies. A common mistake is to write about the companies in general without mentioning the timer.

Mark scheme
  1. 6 marks

    Levels of response (6 marks).
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Thorough analysis and evaluation of both approaches considering their suitability for Jamal's kitchen timer.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Good analysis and simple evaluative points of one or more approaches considering their suitability for the kitchen timer.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Basic analysis of one or two simple points about either approach.
    0 marks: No response or nothing worthy of credit.

    Indicative content (illustrative, not exhaustive; credit any worthy points made in support of the band descriptors): Alessi approach - positives: a playful, characterful form (e.g. an animal or figure) makes the timer fun and memorable and can become a talking point or gift; humour can make a simple task enjoyable; a distinctive look stands out from competitors and can sell at a premium; working with a well-known designer adds appeal. Negatives: decorative features can make the controls less obvious or the time harder to read; extra parts or complex shapes can cost more to make and be harder to clean in a kitchen; a novelty look may date or not suit every kitchen. Braun approach - positives: only the essential controls and a clear display make the timer understandable and quick to use with wet or messy hands; plain forms are easy to clean and suit any kitchen (unobtrusive); fewer parts make it simpler and cheaper to manufacture and more reliable; a timeless look is long-lasting (Rams's principles, which later influenced Apple). Negatives: may look plain or dull and not stand out on a shop shelf; less emotional appeal; harder to justify a premium price. Analysis: identification of how each approach affects function, use, appearance and manufacture of a timer. Evaluation: a justified judgement, e.g. Braun's approach suits the timer's main need of being clear and easy to use, but some Alessi-style character could be added if it does not reduce usability; or the choice depends on the target market (e.g. a gift product vs an everyday tool). Level 3 needs both approaches with a judgement. Accept all other valid responses.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.