Question 1
1 markA designer is designing a wooden bird box for a garden.
Which of these is a point from a manufacturing specification rather than a design specification?
Choose your answer.
- The bird box must suit small birds such as blue tits
- The bird box should blend in with the colours of a garden
- The roof must overhang the front so that rain runs off
- The sides are cut from 12 mm exterior plywood, 150 ± 1 mm wide
Model answer
The sides are cut from 12 mm exterior plywood, 150 ± 1 mm wide
Explanation
A design specification lists what the product must do and be (function, user, aesthetics, size limits) so ideas can be judged against it. A manufacturing specification tells the maker exactly how to make the chosen design: materials, exact sizes, tolerances, processes, sequence and quality checks. The tolerance (± 1 mm) is a clear sign of a manufacturing specification.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
The sides are cut from 12 mm exterior plywood, 150 ± 1 mm wide
If more than one option is given, 0 marks. 'Must suit small birds' states the user/function, a design specification point. 'Should blend in' is an aesthetic requirement, a design specification point. 'The roof must overhang' is a functional requirement of the design, not an instruction for making it. Only the last option gives the exact material, size and tolerance needed to make the part, which belongs in a manufacturing specification.