The owner of a café wants a charging station that customers can use to charge their phones at the tables. She wants it to charge several phones at once, to be safe, to have no trailing cables, to be easy to wipe clean and to suit the café's natural wood interior. Two prototypes have been made.
Prototype A: a bright orange 3D-printed PLA case with four built-in charging cables of different types. It plugs into a mains socket using a 2 m cable.
Prototype B: a walnut-veneered MDF case with a wireless charging pad on top, powered by a rechargeable battery that lasts about one day. It charges one phone at a time.
Analyse and evaluate both prototypes in terms of how well they respond to the client's wants and needs.
Model answer
Prototype A meets the client's most important functional need: it can charge four phones at once, and having different types of cable means it suits most customers' phones. However, it fails several other needs. The 2 m mains cable trails across the floor, which is a trip hazard in a busy café and goes against her wish for no trailing cables, and it can only be used at tables near a socket. The built-in cables could be pulled, damaged or even taken, and would be awkward to wipe around. Its bright orange 3D-printed case clashes with the natural wood interior, and the layer lines of printed PLA are hard to clean. PLA is also only a prototyping material: a mains-powered product would need a durable, flame-retardant case.
Prototype B responds much better to safety and appearance. With no cables at all, it is safe and tidy and can be put on any table. The flat top is easy to wipe clean, and the walnut veneer suits the café's natural wood style. Its weakness is serious, though: it charges only one phone at a time, so it fails the need to charge several phones. Some customers' phones may not support wireless charging, staff would have to recharge it every night, and the MDF would need sealing in case drinks are spilt.
Overall, Prototype B is closer to what the client wants, because safety, cleanliness and appearance matter in a café, but neither prototype fully meets the brief. The best development would keep B's veneered case and rechargeable battery but fit several wireless charging pads so that more customers can charge at once.
Explanation
Level 3 answers go through the client's requirements (several phones, safety, no cables, cleaning, appearance) for both prototypes, say clearly which are met and which are not, and reach a justified conclusion, ideally suggesting how to develop the better prototype. Describing the prototypes without linking features to the client's wants and needs stays in Level 1.