A designer has produced two LED desk lamps for students to use in their bedrooms.
Lamp A is powered from the mains. It has a 1.8 m cable and a plug-in adaptor that changes 230 V mains electricity into 5 V for the lamp.
Lamp B has a built-in rechargeable lithium-ion battery that cannot be removed. It runs for 5 hours at full brightness and takes 3 hours to recharge from a USB charger.
Analyse and evaluate both lamps in terms of their power systems.
Model answer
Lamp A runs from the mains, so it never runs out. A student could study for hours and the lamp would stay at full brightness. With no battery to wear out it should last for many years, and it is cheaper to make and better for the environment because no lithium battery has to be mined, made or disposed of. The adaptor also means only a safe 5 V reaches the lamp. Its weakness is the 1.8 m cable. The lamp can only be used near a socket, so it cannot be moved to a bed or a desk on the other side of the room, and the trailing cable is untidy and could be tripped over.
Lamp B is cordless, so it can be used anywhere: on the desk, in bed or taken to another room, and it still works in a power cut. Five hours is enough for an evening's homework. However, the student has to remember to charge it, and if it goes flat it is unusable for up to 3 hours. Lithium-ion batteries lose capacity after a few hundred charges, and because this battery cannot be removed the whole lamp may be thrown away when it wears out, which adds to e-waste and makes it poorer value.
Overall, I think Lamp A is the better choice for a student with a fixed desk near a socket, because it is reliable, cheaper and longer lasting. Lamp B is better for a small bedroom with no socket by the desk, but it would be improved by a replaceable battery and by letting it be used while charging.
Explanation
Level 3 answers analyse both lamps, linking each feature of the power system to its effect on the student (reliability, portability, safety, product life and the environment), and then make a reasoned judgement. A common pitfall is to describe the lamps without evaluating, or to write only about one lamp. Points such as the non-removable battery shortening the product's life, and the trailing cable, show real analysis.