Students in a design and technology workshop often cut card with a craft knife against the edge of a ruler. A teacher is choosing between two 300 mm rulers.
Ruler A: stainless steel, 1 mm thick, with the markings etched into the surface.
Ruler B: acrylic, 3 mm thick, transparent, with the markings printed on the back.
Analyse and evaluate the suitability of each ruler for the workshop, in terms of the physical and working properties of the materials.
Model answer
Ruler A is stainless steel, which is a hard material. When a student runs a craft knife along its edge the blade cannot cut into the steel, so the edge stays perfectly straight and every cut is accurate. Steel is also tough, so the ruler will not snap if it is dropped on the floor, and it is elastic, so if it is bent it springs back straight. Stainless steel does not rust, and because the markings are etched into the surface they will not rub off. It is denser than acrylic, so it is heavier and less likely to slip while cutting. Its main drawbacks are that it is opaque, so students cannot see the work underneath, and it costs more.
Ruler B is acrylic. It is transparent, so students can see their lines through it and position it accurately, and it is light. The printed markings on the back are protected from wear. However, acrylic is much softer than steel, so a craft knife will soon nick and shave the edge. The edge then becomes uneven, the cuts are no longer straight and the blade could slip towards the student's fingers. Acrylic is also brittle, so the ruler could crack or snap if it is dropped, leaving sharp edges, and its surface scratches easily, making it harder to see through.
Overall, Ruler A is far more suitable for cutting in the workshop because its hardness and toughness make it accurate, long-lasting and safer. Ruler B is still useful for drawing and measuring, where being able to see through it is an advantage, but it should not be used as a cutting edge.
Explanation
The top level needs both rulers analysed using named properties (hardness, toughness, elasticity, density, transparency) linked to what happens in the workshop, plus a judgement about which suits which job. Simply saying 'steel is strong' or 'acrylic is see-through' without explaining the effect stays in Level 1. The key point is hardness: a craft knife damages a soft acrylic edge but not a steel one.