A designer is developing a hand-cranked wooden toy for children aged 5 to 8. When the handle is turned, a model fish rises slowly out of painted 'waves' and then drops suddenly back into them. Two cam mechanisms are being considered.
Design 1: an eccentric cam with a flat follower
Design 2: a snail (drop) cam with a knife-edge follower
Analyse and evaluate both designs for this toy.
Model answer
Design 1 uses an eccentric cam: a circular cam turning on an off-centre shaft. This gives a smooth, continuous rise and fall, with the rise and fall taking the same time and no sudden drop, so the fish would just bob gently up and down. That does not meet the main requirement of a slow rise and a sudden drop. Its advantages are that it works whichever way the handle is turned, so a young child cannot jam it by turning backwards, it is quiet, and it is cheap and easy to make by drilling a wooden disc off-centre. The flat follower has a large contact area, so it wears the wooden cam less than a pointed follower, although it causes more friction than a roller would.
Design 2 uses a snail cam, which lifts the follower gradually through almost the whole turn and then lets it drop suddenly off a step. This is exactly the movement needed: the fish rises slowly and then splashes back into the waves, which children would find fun. However, a snail cam must only turn one way. Children aged 5 to 8 are likely to turn the handle backwards, and the follower would then hit the step and jam, possibly breaking the toy. The knife-edge follower would follow the sharp drop accurately, but its narrow edge would wear quickly and dig into a wooden cam, and the sudden impact adds wear and noise.
Overall, Design 2 is the better choice because only it gives the movement the toy needs. I would improve it by using a small roller follower, which reduces friction and wear while still dropping off the step, and by adding a simple ratchet so that the handle can only turn one way. Design 1 is more robust but fails the main requirement of the toy.
Explanation
Top-level answers analyse the movement each cam gives against the brief (slow rise, sudden drop), consider practical issues such as turning direction, follower wear and the age of the users, and finish with a reasoned judgement, ideally suggesting improvements. Answers that only describe the cams, or deal with one design, stay in Level 1 or 2. Remember that a snail cam's one-way action is a real risk with young children.