Question 1
1 markEwan works out the weighted mean of the two values 3.2 and 4.6, using the weights 5 and 2 respectively. His answer is 5.8
Without working out the weighted mean, explain how you know that Ewan's answer must be wrong.
Model answer
A weighted mean is always between the smallest and the largest of the values being averaged, here between 3.2 and 4.6. Ewan's answer, 5.8, is greater than both values, so it must be wrong.
Explanation
Whatever the weights, a weighted mean is a kind of average of the values, so it cannot be smaller than the smallest value or larger than the largest. It is also nearer the value with the larger weight (here 3.2). Checking that an answer lies in this range is a quick test for errors such as dividing by the wrong total.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for a weighted mean must lie between the smallest and the largest values (between 3.2 and 4.6), but 5.8 is greater than 4.6 oe
Accept 'a mean cannot be bigger than the biggest value'. Accept 'it should be closer to 3.2, as 3.2 has the larger weight, but 5.8 is above both values'. B0 for 'the weights are wrong' or 'he divided by the wrong number' with no reference to the values 3.2 and 4.6. Working out the correct weighted mean (3.6) without the reason does not answer the question and scores B0.