Question 1
1 markA transport survey asked 60 commuters which bus route they use. The routes are numbered 1, 4, 7, 12, 23, 38 and 85.
Ruth typed the route numbers into a spreadsheet, and the software calculated that the mean route number is 23.7
Explain why this mean is not a useful statistic.
Model answer
The route numbers are labels that name the routes; they do not measure or count anything. Route 85 is not 'more' than route 7, so adding the numbers and dividing by 60 gives a number with no meaning. The software calculated it only because the labels were typed in as numbers.
Explanation
Software will calculate any statistic from whatever numbers it is given, so the user must decide whether the statistic makes sense for the type of data. Route numbers are qualitative (categorical) data that happen to be written as numbers. For data like these, the mode (the route used most) or a bar chart of the number of commuters using each route is appropriate.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for the route numbers are only labels (names) for the routes, not measurements or counts, so their mean has no meaning oe
Accept 'the data are qualitative (categorical)', 'the numbers are just names, so adding them up means nothing' or 'if the routes were numbered differently the mean would change'. B0 for 'there is no route 23.7' or 'the mean is not a whole number' on their own (a mean of counts need not be a whole number either). B0 for 'the mean is affected by the extreme value 85' (that criticism is about genuine numerical data). Ignore a correct suggestion such as 'use the mode'.