Question 1
1 markZara models the number of days in a week on which it rains in her town with the binomial distribution B(7, 0.3).
Give one reason, in context, why this model may not be suitable.
Model answer
Rain on different days is probably not independent: if it rains on Monday, the wet weather may continue, so rain on Tuesday is more likely. A binomial model needs the days to be independent, so B(7, 0.3) may not be suitable.
Explanation
A binomial model needs a fixed number of independent trials, two outcomes for each trial and the same probability of success on every trial. Here there are 7 days and each day is either wet or dry, so those conditions hold, but weather comes in spells, so the days are not independent, and the chance of rain changes with the weather pattern. Reasons must be given in context, not just as general conditions.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for a correct reason in context, e.g. whether it rains on one day is not independent of whether it rains on the next day (wet or dry weather often lasts for several days) / the probability of rain may not be 0.3 on every day of the week (it depends on the weather at the time)
oe. The reason must be about the days not being independent or the probability not being the same for each day, and it must be in context (rain, days, weather). B0 for 'the trials may not be independent' or 'p may not be constant' with no context. B0 for 'there is not a fixed number of trials' (there are 7 days), 'there are more than two outcomes' (each day either has rain or does not) or 'it could rain more than 7 times'. Ignore extraneous non-contradictory comments.