Question 1
1 markA gym asked 120 of its members which types of class they had been to in the last month. Members could name as many types of class as they liked, and the 120 members gave 274 answers altogether.
The gym manager wants to show the proportion of the members who had been to each type of class. She plans to use a pie chart.
Explain why a pie chart is not suitable for this.
Model answer
Each member could name several types of class, so many members would be counted in more than one sector. The sectors of a pie chart must be separate parts of one whole (here the 120 members), but the answers add up to 274, so the proportions of members for the different classes would add up to more than 100%. A bar chart of the number of members who went to each type of class would be better.
Explanation
A pie chart shows how one whole is divided into parts that do not overlap, so each member must appear in exactly one sector. When people can give several answers, the frequencies add up to more than the number of people, and the percentages of people add up to more than 100%, which cannot be shown as sectors of one circle.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for an explanation that members could give more than one answer, so the categories overlap / the 274 answers do not split the 120 members into separate parts of one whole oe
oe, eg 'some members would be counted in more than one sector', 'the percentages of members would add up to more than 100%', 'the frequencies add up to 274, not 120'. B0 for 'there are too many categories', 'a bar chart is better' or 'it is hard to read' with no reason linked to the members giving several answers.