Question 1
1 markIn a large secondary school, half of the students are girls.
Amir takes a random sample of 10 students from the school.
Bella takes a random sample of 100 students from the school.
Which sample is more likely to be at least 70% girls?
Choose your answer.
- Amir's sample
- Bella's sample
- Both are equally likely
- It is impossible to tell
Model answer
A small sample varies much more from the population than a large one.
In a sample of 10, getting 7 or more girls happens quite often (about 1 time in 6). In a sample of 100, the proportion of girls is almost always close to 50%, so 70% or more girls is very unlikely.
Answer: Amir's sample
Explanation
Larger random samples generally give better estimates of a population proportion, because the proportion in a large sample tends to be close to the population value. So an extreme sample proportion, such as 70% girls when the population has 50%, is much more likely in a small sample. A common misconception is that, because the population proportion is the same, both samples are equally likely to be extreme.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for Amir's sample cao
Accept any unambiguous indication of Amir's sample (the sample of 10). 'Bella's sample' (the idea that a bigger sample gives more chances to pick girls), 'Both are equally likely' (the idea that the proportion of girls in a sample does not depend on the sample size) and 'It is impossible to tell' score B0. More than one option chosen scores B0. For information: the probabilities are about 0.17 for the sample of 10 and about 0.00004 for the sample of 100.