Question 1
1 markA school has 900 students. To choose a sample, Mr Hall picks one of the 26 letters of the alphabet at random and chooses every student whose surname begins with that letter.
Explain why this is not a simple random sample of the students.
Model answer
In a simple random sample of a given size, every possible group of students is equally likely to be chosen. Here students with the same initial are always chosen together, and students with different initials can never be chosen together, so most groups of students can never be the sample. The size of the sample also depends on the letter: S would give many students, but X might give none.
Explanation
A simple random sample needs more than every member having the same chance: the members must be chosen independently, so that every possible sample of that size is equally likely. Choosing whole groups, such as everyone with one initial, gives each student a 1 in 26 chance but is really a form of cluster sampling, and members of the same family, who share a surname, would always be chosen together.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for explaining that not every possible sample (group of students) is equally likely: students whose surnames begin with the same letter are always chosen together, and students with different initials can never be in the sample together / the size of the sample is not fixed: it depends on the letter (eg many surnames begin with S, very few with X, and some letters may give no students at all)
oe. Either idea scores the mark. Do not accept 'not every student has the same chance of being chosen' (each student has a probability of \(\dfrac{1}{26}\)), 'it is not random' or 'it is biased' with no reason.