Question 1
1 markA sensor in a field on a farm in England records the air temperature every hour. Here are the temperatures, in °C, that it recorded from 9 am to 4 pm on one day in May.
11.4 12.6 13.9 -99.9 15.2 15.8 16.1 15.5
Explain why -99.9 °C is likely to be an error rather than a genuine temperature.
Model answer
The readings either side are 13.9 °C and 15.2 °C, so the temperature cannot have dropped by more than 100 °C in an hour and then risen again. A temperature of -99.9 °C never happens in England, especially in May. The value is probably a code that the sensor records when it fails to take a reading.
Explanation
An outlier spotted by inspection is not automatically an error: you have to use the context. Here the value is physically impossible, so it must be an error (or a missing-data code) and should not be used in calculations such as the mean temperature. Saying only that it is very different from the other values gains no credit.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for a reason in context, e.g. the temperature could not fall by over 100 °C in an hour and be back up to 15.2 °C an hour later / no temperature anywhere near -99.9 °C happens in England (let alone in May) / -99.9 is likely to be a code recorded when the sensor gives no reading
oe. The reason must use the context: what temperatures are possible, or the readings either side of it. B0 for 'it is an outlier', 'it is much lower than the other temperatures' or 'it is negative' alone (these only restate the data). Ignore any suggestion of what to do with the value.