Question 1
1 markA first-aid charity wants to compare two methods of teaching adults to give chest compressions in CPR, Method X and Method Y. After the training, each person's chest compressions on a training dummy will be scored.
Explain why it would not be appropriate to train each person with both methods, one after the other.
Model answer
A person who has already learned chest compressions with the first method cannot forget what they have learned. When they are trained with the second method they start with skill and practice they did not have before, so any improvement could come from the first method. The two methods would not be compared fairly, so the charity should use two different groups of people, for example matched pairs.
Explanation
Testing the same people under both conditions controls differences between people, but only works when the first condition does not change the people. A skill that has been learned cannot be undone, so here two groups are needed; matched pairs make the two groups as alike as possible.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for once a person has learned to give chest compressions with the first method, they cannot unlearn it, so their score after the second method would be affected by what they learned (and practised) with the first: the methods could not be compared fairly; separate groups (e.g. matched pairs) are needed
oe. Must refer to the first method's learning or practice carrying over to the second. B0 for 'it would take too long', 'people would get bored' or 'it is not fair' with no reason.