Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Edexcel GCSE Statistics (Higher Paper 2) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
The statistical enquiry cycle
Statistical enquiry cycle stages 1 and 2; (a) Planning: 1a.01, 1a.02, 1a.03
Statistical enquiry cycle: planning and collecting
Statistical enquiry cycle stages 3, 4 and 5
Statistical enquiry cycle: interpreting and evaluating
Unit 2
The collection of data
(b) Types of data: 1b.01, 1b.02, 1b.03
Types of data and variables
(b) Types of data: 1b.04; (d) Collecting data: 1d.01, 1d.02
Primary and secondary data, reliability and validity
(c) Population and sampling: 1c.01, 1c.02, 1c.03
Populations, sampling frames and non-random sampling
(c) Population and sampling: 1c.04, 1c.05
Random and systematic sampling
(c) Population and sampling: 1c.06
Stratified sampling
(d) Collecting data: 1d.05, 1d.06
Problems with collected data and cleaning data
Unit 3
Processing, representing and analysing data
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.01
Tabulation, tallies, pictograms and two-way tables
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.01, 2a.02
Pie charts and comparative pie charts
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.01
Stem and leaf diagrams
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.02
Population pyramids, choropleth maps and 2D and 3D diagrams
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.04
Histograms and frequency density
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.05, 2a.06, 2a.07, 2a.08
Choosing representations and misleading diagrams
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.09, 2a.10
Skewness
(b) Measures of central tendency: 2b.01, 2b.02, 2b.03
Mode, median and mean
(b) Measures of central tendency: 2b.01
Weighted mean and geometric mean
(c) Measures of dispersion: 2c.01, 2c.06
Standard deviation and standardised scores
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.03; (c) Measures of dispersion: 2c.02, 2c.03
Box plots and outliers
(b) Measures of central tendency: 2b.03; (c) Measures of dispersion: 2c.04, 2c.05
Comparing distributions
(d) Further summary statistics: 2d.01
Index numbers
(d) Further summary statistics: 2d.02
Rates of change
(e) Scatter diagrams and correlation: 2e.01, 2e.02, 2e.03
Scatter diagrams, correlation and causation
(e) Scatter diagrams and correlation: 2e.04
Lines of best fit and regression lines
(e) Scatter diagrams and correlation: 2e.05, 2e.06, 2e.07, 2e.08
Spearman's rank and product moment correlation coefficients
(f) Time series: 2f.01, 2f.02; (b) 2b.01 mean seasonal variation
Time series, moving averages and seasonal variation
(g) Quality assurance: 2g.01, 2g.02
Quality assurance and control charts
(h) Estimation: 2h.01, 2h.02, 2h.03
Estimation, sample size and capture-recapture
Unit 4
Probability
3. Probability: 3p.01, 3p.02, 3p.03, 3p.04
Probability, expected frequency and risk
3. Probability: 3p.05, 3p.06, 3p.10
Experimental and theoretical probability and bias
3. Probability: 3p.11
Binomial distribution
3. Probability: 3p.12, 3p.13
Normal distribution
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/40

Experiments, extraneous variables and control groups

Practise 14 exam-style questions on Experiments, extraneous variables and control groups for Edexcel GCSE Statistics (Higher Paper 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 14 questions
  • 1–6 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
14 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

1 mark

A first-aid charity wants to compare two methods of teaching adults to give chest compressions in CPR, Method X and Method Y. After the training, each person's chest compressions on a training dummy will be scored.

Explain why it would not be appropriate to train each person with both methods, one after the other.

Model answer

A person who has already learned chest compressions with the first method cannot forget what they have learned. When they are trained with the second method they start with skill and practice they did not have before, so any improvement could come from the first method. The two methods would not be compared fairly, so the charity should use two different groups of people, for example matched pairs.

Explanation

Testing the same people under both conditions controls differences between people, but only works when the first condition does not change the people. A skill that has been learned cannot be undone, so here two groups are needed; matched pairs make the two groups as alike as possible.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    B1 for once a person has learned to give chest compressions with the first method, they cannot unlearn it, so their score after the second method would be affected by what they learned (and practised) with the first: the methods could not be compared fairly; separate groups (e.g. matched pairs) are needed

    oe. Must refer to the first method's learning or practice carrying over to the second. B0 for 'it would take too long', 'people would get bored' or 'it is not fair' with no reason.

Question 2

2 marks

Rhys is comparing how long two brands of outdoor wood paint take to dry. Each day for 20 days, he paints a test board with one of the brands and times how long the paint takes to dry. He does the tests outdoors, where the temperature changes from day to day. He cannot control the temperature, so he records it during each test.

Explain why Rhys records the temperature.
Explain how he could use the temperature readings when he compares the two brands.

Model answer

Temperature could affect how long paint takes to dry: paint usually dries more slowly on cold days. So the temperature is an extraneous variable that could make one brand look better than the other.

Rhys can check whether the two brands were tested at similar temperatures, for example by comparing the mean temperature on the days each brand was tested. If they were not, he can compare the brands using tests done at similar temperatures, or allow for this in his conclusion.

Explanation

Extraneous variables should be controlled where possible. When one cannot be controlled, recording it lets the investigator check whether it differs between the groups and take it into account. Testing both brands on the same day, side by side, would control the weather completely; alternating the brands from day to day would at least spread the changes fairly between them.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    B1 for the temperature is an extraneous variable: it may affect how long the paint takes to dry, so it could cause a difference between the drying times that is not caused by the brand

    oe. Accept 'paint dries more slowly when it is cold'. B0 for 'to see what the temperature is' with no link to the drying times.

  2. 1 mark

    B1 for check that the two brands were tested at similar temperatures (e.g. compare the mean temperature for each brand) / compare the two brands using tests done at similar temperatures / take any difference in temperature into account in his conclusion

    oe. This mark is independent of the first. B0 for 'do the tests indoors' or 'control the temperature' (the question says he cannot). B0 for 'work out the mean temperature' with no link to comparing the brands.

Question 3

3 marks

A researcher compared 50 people who chose to use a high-protection sunscreen with 50 people who chose not to use any sunscreen. Over one summer, more of the people who used the sunscreen got sunburnt.

Explain how an extraneous variable could explain this result.
Describe how the study could be changed to control this variable.

Model answer

An extraneous variable is the amount of time each person spends in strong sunshine. People who sunbathe or go on beach holidays are the most likely to choose to use sunscreen, and they are also the most likely to get sunburnt. So the sunscreen group may have had more sunburn because they spent more time in the sun, not because the sunscreen made sunburn more likely.

The study could use matched pairs, pairing people who spend similar amounts of time in the sun and have similar skin types, so that this variable is controlled.

Explanation

When people choose their own group, the groups can differ in ways that affect the result, and an extraneous variable can even make a treatment look harmful. Here time in the sun affects both who uses sunscreen and who gets burnt. Matching, recording the variable or random allocation stops it distorting the comparison.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    B1 for a suitable extraneous variable, e.g. the amount of time spent in strong sunshine (sunbathing, beach holidays, outdoor sport) / skin type (people who burn easily are more likely to use sunscreen)

    oe. B0 for 'whether they used sunscreen' (the explanatory variable) or 'sunburn' (the response variable).

  2. 1 mark

    B1 for explaining the effect, e.g. people who spend a lot of time in strong sunshine are more likely to choose to use sunscreen and are also more likely to get sunburnt, so the sunscreen group had more sunburn because of the time in the sun, not because of the sunscreen

    Dependent on the previous mark. Must link the variable both to choosing sunscreen (the groups) and to sunburn. B0 for 'the sunscreen does not work'.

  3. 1 mark

    B1 for a suitable change, e.g. use matched pairs, pairing people with similar time in the sun and skin type / record the time each person spends in strong sunshine and compare people with similar amounts / put people into the groups at random rather than letting them choose

    oe. This mark is independent of the first two. The change must control (or allow for) the variable given. B0 for 'use more people' or 'test for longer'.

Question 4

4 marks

A researcher wants to test whether an app that reminds people when to go to bed increases how long teenagers sleep. 12 volunteers aged 16 to 18 will wear sleep trackers for four weeks. Six will use the app and six will not. At the end she will compare the mean time each volunteer slept per night in the fourth week. She considers two designs.

Design 1: put the 12 volunteers into two groups of six at random.
Design 2: record how long each volunteer sleeps each night for one week before the trial, put the volunteers into six pairs with similar mean sleep times, and toss a coin to decide which volunteer in each pair uses the app.

Explain why Design 2 is likely to give a fairer comparison than Design 1.
Give one disadvantage of Design 2.
Describe how the researcher should compare the results if she uses Design 2.

Model answer

In Design 2, the two volunteers in each pair already sleep for similar lengths of time, so the group that uses the app and the group that does not are matched on how long they usually sleep, which is the variable most likely to affect the results. With only 12 volunteers, Design 1 could by chance put most of the long sleepers into one group, and then a difference at the end could be caused by their usual sleep rather than the app.

Disadvantage: it takes an extra week to record the sleep times and form the pairs, and volunteers with similar sleep times may still differ in other ways, such as how early their school or college starts.

The researcher should find the difference between the two volunteers' mean sleep times in each pair (app minus no app) and work out the mean of the six differences.

Explanation

With small groups, random allocation can easily give unbalanced groups by chance; matched pairs control the most important extraneous variable directly, while the coin toss keeps the allocation within each pair fair. The analysis should match the design: compare within each pair, using the differences.

Mark scheme
  1. 2 marks

    B2 for two different reasons (B1 for each) from: in Design 2 the volunteers in each pair start with similar sleep times, so the two groups are matched on how long they usually sleep (the extraneous variable most likely to affect the results) / with only 12 volunteers, random allocation in Design 1 could by chance put more of the volunteers who usually sleep longer in one group, so a difference could be caused by their usual sleep rather than the app

    1 mark for each different reason, max 2. B0 for 'matched pairs are fairer' with no reason. B0 for 'Design 1 is not random' (it is).

  2. 1 mark

    B1 for a disadvantage, e.g. it takes an extra week to record the sleep times and form the pairs / volunteers with similar sleep times may still differ in other ways (e.g. school or college start times, screen use, caffeine, part-time jobs) / if one volunteer drops out, their partner's result cannot be used / it may be hard to find pairs with very similar sleep times

    oe. B0 for 'it is not random' (the coin toss is random). B0 for 'it is more expensive' with no reason.

  3. 1 mark

    B1 for compare the results within each pair, e.g. find the difference (app minus no app) in mean sleep time for each pair and work out the mean of the six differences / count in how many pairs the volunteer who used the app slept longer

    oe. Accept 'compare each volunteer's change in sleep time with their partner's'. B0 for 'compare the two groups' with no reference to the pairs.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.