Question 1
1 markA cycling charity wants to estimate the proportion of cyclists in a town who have cycled at night without lights in the last month, which is against the law. It will use the random response technique. Each cyclist will be given a random outcome, then either tick Yes or answer the question honestly, depending on the outcome.
Which of these is the most suitable way for each cyclist to get the random outcome?
A Think of a whole number from 1 to 6.
B Roll a fair dice where nobody else can see it.
C Roll a fair dice and show the result to the interviewer.
D Use the last digit of their house number.
Choose your answer.
- A
- B
- C
- D
Model answer
B
A fair dice gives every outcome the same chance, and rolling it where nobody else can see it means that nobody knows whether a cyclist's Yes was forced by the dice or is a true answer.
Explanation
The random outcome must be both random and private. A number that someone thinks of is not random, because people can choose the outcome that suits them. If the interviewer sees the dice, a Yes from a cyclist who was told to answer the question is a real admission, so the protection is lost. A house number is fixed and can be known by others.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for B
Accept the method written out in words. More than one letter given scores B0. A is not random: people choose their own number, and someone who wants to avoid the question can pick a number that tells them to tick Yes. C is not private: the interviewer knows which cyclists had to answer the question, so their Yes answers are not hidden. D is not random, and other people may know the house number.