Question 1
1 markA school nurse records the reason for each visit that a student makes to the medical room: headache, injury, feeling sick or other. She records the visits for each week in a tally chart.
Give one disadvantage of recording the visits in a tally chart, rather than writing down each visit in a list as it happens.
Model answer
A tally chart records only how many visits there were for each reason: each visit is just one mark in a row. The order and the times of the visits are lost, so the nurse could not tell, for example, whether most headaches happen in the afternoon, or whether the same student visited several times.
Explanation
A tally chart is quick to fill in and gives the frequency of each category straight away, but it keeps nothing else about each item. A list written as the visits happen keeps their order (and anything else noted, such as the time or the student), so the data can be looked at in other ways later. An answer must say what information is lost: 'it is less accurate' or 'it is harder' does not score.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for a correct disadvantage: information about the individual visits is lost, eg the order or the times of the visits are not recorded / the nurse cannot tell which day each visit happened / she cannot tell whether the same student made several visits
oe, eg 'you can't see when the headaches happened', 'the tally chart only shows how many visits there were for each reason', 'the visits can't be sorted in another way later, eg by year group'. B0 for vague answers with no reason, eg 'it is less accurate', 'it is harder to read', 'it takes longer', 'it is easy to make mistakes'. B0 for 'you cannot find the totals' (the tally chart gives the frequency of each reason). Ignore extraneous non-contradictory comments.