Question 1
1 markAt a school competition, students threw paper aeroplanes. Kai drew a histogram of the distances, d m, that the aeroplanes flew. On his histogram, the bars for the classes \(2 < d \le 4\) and \(4 < d \le 8\) are the same height.
Kai says,
"The same number of paper aeroplanes are in each of these two classes."
Explain why Kai is wrong.
Model answer
In a histogram the area of a bar shows the frequency, and the height is the frequency density. The two bars are the same height, but the class \(4 < d \le 8\) is 4 m wide and the class \(2 < d \le 4\) is 2 m wide. So the bar for \(4 < d \le 8\) has twice the area: twice as many paper aeroplanes flew between 4 m and 8 m.
Explanation
Equal heights mean equal frequency densities, not equal frequencies. Frequency = frequency density × class width, so the wider class has the greater frequency. Comparing heights alone is the common error when class widths are unequal.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for the frequency is shown by the area of a bar (frequency density × class width), and the class \(4 < d \le 8\) is twice as wide, so it has twice as many aeroplanes oe
Accept 'frequency = frequency density × width, and the width of 4 to 8 is 4 m but the width of 2 to 4 is 2 m' or 'the bar for 4 to 8 has twice the area'. B0 for 'the classes have different widths' alone, with no reference to area or to the frequencies; B0 for 'the heights show frequency density' alone.