Question 1
1 markA school nurse is investigating how much water students drink during a school day. On one day she stops students in the corridor at different times between 8:30 am and 3:30 pm and asks each of them,
'How many drinks of water have you had today?'
Explain why the time at which she asks each student is a problem for her investigation.
Model answer
A student asked at 8:30 am has had only a short part of the day to drink anything, but a student asked at 3:30 pm has had most of the school day. The answers cover different lengths of time, so they cannot be fairly compared, and early answers will tend to be smaller.
Explanation
Time factors matter when planning data collection: a question about 'today' means something different at 8:30 am and at 3:30 pm. Asking every student at the same time, for example at the end of the day, or asking about a complete period such as 'yesterday', makes the answers comparable.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for students asked early in the day have had much less time to drink water than students asked later, so their answers will tend to be smaller: the answers cover different lengths of time and cannot be fairly compared
oe. Must link the time of asking to how much of the day has passed (or to the size of the answers). Accept 'a student asked at 8:30 am has hardly started the day'. B0 for 'students may forget' or 'the drinks may be different sizes' (true, but not about the time of asking). B0 for 'some students will not be in school'.