Question 1
1 markA teacher tried a new revision app with 6 students. All 6 students got higher marks in their next test.
Another teacher plans to repeat the trial with a different group of 6 students.
Explain why the second trial may not give the same result.
Model answer
Six students is a very small sample. The improvement could have happened by chance (for example, these 6 students may have revised harder anyway), and a different group of 6 could easily behave differently. A result based on a much larger sample would be more reliable and more likely to be replicated.
Explanation
Results from small samples vary a lot from one sample to the next, so a conclusion from 6 people may not be replicated when the investigation is repeated. Larger samples give more reliable results. Saying only that the sample is small, without saying what that does to the result, does not explain why the second trial may differ.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for with a sample as small as 6, the result could easily be due to chance (the 6 students may not be typical), so a different 6 students could give a different result
oe, e.g. 'small samples vary a lot, so the result may not be repeated (replicated)' or 'six students are too few to be representative'. The answer must link the small sample to the result changing or being due to chance. B0 for 'the sample is small' alone, or for 'the students might cheat', 'the test might be easier' or 'the other teacher may use the app differently' with no reference to sample size.