Question 1
1 markAt a cafe, for a customer chosen at random,
the probability that the customer pays by card is 0.6
the probability that the customer pays by phone is 0.3
Jo says,
"The probability that the customer pays by card or by phone is 0.6 + 0.3 = 0.9"
What must be true about the events 'the customer pays by card' and 'the customer pays by phone' for Jo's method to be correct?
Model answer
The events must be mutually exclusive: a customer cannot pay by both card and phone. Then P(card or phone) = P(card) + P(phone).
Explanation
The addition law P(A or B) = P(A) + P(B) works only for mutually exclusive events. If some customers paid partly by card and partly by phone, the general addition law would be needed: P(card or phone) = 0.6 + 0.3 − P(card and phone). Independence is about multiplying probabilities, not adding them.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for they must be mutually exclusive (oe, e.g. 'a customer cannot pay by both card and phone')
Accept 'P(card and phone) = 0' or 'the events cannot both happen'. B0 for 'independent', 'exhaustive', 'equally likely' or 'the probabilities must add up to less than 1'. A correct and an incorrect answer (e.g. 'mutually exclusive and independent') scores B0.