The big idea
No two individuals in a population are exactly alike. Variation is the differences in the characteristics of individuals in a population. Some differences come from the genes an organism inherits, some from the conditions it grows up in, and most from both together. New genetic variants arise from mutations, and this variation is what lets a species change over time.
Genes, the environment, or both
Variation may be due to differences in:
- the genes they have inherited (genetic causes);
- the conditions in which they have developed (environmental causes);
- a combination of genes and the environment.
| Cause | Examples in humans | Examples in plants |
|---|
| Genes only | Blood group, natural eye colour, inherited disorders such as cystic fibrosis | Flower colour in pea plants (purple or white) |
| Environment only | Scars, tattoos, the language you speak, accent | Leaves damaged by insects or wind |
| Both | Height, body mass, skin colour | Height, number of fruits, mass of seeds |
The genome (all of an organism's genetic material) and its interaction with the environment shape the phenotype. The genes set what the organism could become; the environment affects what it actually becomes. For example, a plant may have alleles for growing tall, but with little light it makes less glucose by photosynthesis, so it stays short. Height in humans depends on many genes, but also on diet and health.
Telling the causes apart
- Identical twins have the same genes, so any differences between them must be caused by the environment. Twins brought up apart are especially useful.
- Clones of a plant (for example, cuttings) also have identical genes. Grow them in different conditions, and any differences are environmental.
- If a characteristic is caused only by genes, identical twins always match. If identical twins match more often than non-identical twins, but not always, both genes and the environment are involved.
Using twin data
Scientists studied pairs of twins in which at least one twin had a type of allergy. Both twins had the allergy in 82% of identical pairs but only 30% of non-identical pairs. What do the results show?
Identical twins have the same genes, but non-identical twins share only some of their alleles. Both twins have the allergy far more often in identical pairs (82%) than in non-identical pairs (30%), so genes affect the allergy.
But it is not 100% in identical twins: in 18% of identical pairs, only one twin has it. With the same genes, that difference must be caused by the environment.
So the allergy is caused by a combination of genes and the environment.
Genetic variation and mutations
There is usually extensive genetic variation within a population of a species. You need to know where it comes from.
- All variants arise from mutations. A mutation is a change in the DNA. Mutations occur continuously.
- Sexual reproduction shuffles existing variants into new combinations, but only mutation makes brand-new ones.
- Most variants have no effect on the phenotype; some influence the phenotype; very few determine the phenotype on their own.
Very rarely, a mutation leads to a new phenotype. If the new phenotype is suited to an environmental change, it can lead to a relatively rapid change in the species. Individuals with it are more likely to survive and reproduce, so the new variant spreads through the population over a few generations.
A well-known example is the peppered moth. A mutation produced a dark-winged form. When soot from factories blackened tree bark in industrial areas of 19th-century Britain, the dark moths were better hidden from birds, so more of them survived and bred. Within about 50 years most moths in those areas were dark.
Remember
- Variation: differences in the characteristics of individuals in a population.
- Causes: genes inherited, the conditions of development (environment), or a combination of both.
- There is usually extensive genetic variation within a population.
- All variants arise from mutations: most have no effect on the phenotype, some influence it, very few determine it.
- A rare new phenotype suited to an environmental change can lead to a relatively rapid change in the species.
Common mistakes
- Defining variation as differences between species. It is differences between individuals in a population (of the same species).
- Saying sexual reproduction or meiosis creates new variants. They mix existing ones; all variants arise from mutations.
- Saying "mutations are always harmful". Most have no effect, and a few are useful.
- Saying that organisms "develop" a useful mutation when they need it. Mutations happen randomly and continuously; individuals that already have a useful variant survive and pass it on.
- Writing just "the environment" as a reason. Name the factor, such as diet, light, water or mineral ions.
Exam tip
"Suggest reasons why" questions about differences between plants or people usually want one genetic reason and one environmental reason, each with a named factor. If the organisms are clones or identical twins, say so: "they have identical genes, so the differences must be caused by the environment".