The big idea
Genetic engineering is a process which involves modifying the genome of an organism by introducing a gene from another organism to give a desired characteristic. It works because all organisms read DNA in the same way, so a human gene put into a bacterium still codes for the human protein. You need to know its uses and weigh up its benefits and risks.
How it works and what it is used for
Genes from the chromosomes of humans and other organisms can be 'cut out' and transferred to the cells of other organisms. The organism that receives a gene makes the protein it codes for, so it gains the new characteristic.
| Organism modified | Gene added | Result |
|---|
| Bacteria | The human insulin gene | The bacteria make human insulin, used to treat diabetes |
| Crop plants | A gene for a toxin that kills insects | Crops resistant to insect attack |
| Crop plants | A gene for resistance to a weedkiller | Crops resistant to herbicides |
| Crop plants | Genes for disease resistance or fruit quality | Crops resistant to diseases, or with bigger, better fruits |
Crops that have had their genes modified in this way are called genetically modified (GM) crops. GM crops generally show increased yields:
- Insect-resistant crops are damaged less by insect pests, so more of each plant survives to be harvested.
- Herbicide-resistant crops can be sprayed with a herbicide that kills the weeds but not the crop, so the crop has less competition for light, water and mineral ions.
In medicine, insulin made by GM bacteria is identical to human insulin and can be made cheaply in large amounts. Modern medical research is also exploring the possibility of using genetic modification to overcome some inherited disorders, such as cystic fibrosis, by putting a working copy of a gene into a patient's cells.
Genetic engineering and selective breeding
Both change the genes of organisms to give useful characteristics, but:
| Genetic engineering | Selective breeding |
|---|
| Can move a gene between completely different species | Only uses alleles already present in organisms that can interbreed |
| Can give the characteristic in one generation | Takes many generations |
| Transfers one chosen gene | Mixes many genes, so unwanted characteristics may be passed on too |
Benefits, risks and objections
Potential benefits
- More food from the same area of land, to feed a growing population.
- Less insecticide sprayed, which saves money and harms fewer other insects.
- Crops can be given extra nutrients, such as vitamins, for people with a poor diet.
- Medicines such as insulin made reliably and cheaply, without using animals.
- Some inherited disorders might one day be cured rather than just treated.
Risks and concerns
- Effects on populations of wild flowers and insects: herbicide sprayed on herbicide-resistant crops kills the wild flowers in and around the fields, so insects that feed on their nectar and pollen lose their food.
- Genes could spread in pollen to related wild plants, producing weeds the herbicide cannot kill.
- Some people feel the effects of eating GM crops on human health have not been fully explored: GM crops have only been widely eaten for a few decades, and long-term effects could take years to appear.
- Insect pests can evolve resistance to the toxin in an insect-resistant crop, and GM seed can be too expensive for poorer farmers.
- Most treatments for inherited disorders are still being researched: the gene could end up in the wrong place in the DNA, and changing gametes or embryos would affect future generations.
Some people object because they feel it is unnatural or wrong to move genes between species, or because of concerns for the welfare of GM animals.
Higher tier only
The main steps of genetic engineering
- Enzymes are used to isolate (cut out) the required gene.
- The gene is inserted into a vector, usually a bacterial plasmid or a virus. The plasmid is cut open with the same enzyme, so the cut ends match and the gene can be joined in.
- The vector is used to insert the gene into the required cells.
- Genes are transferred to the cells of animals, plants or microorganisms at an early stage in their development. As the organism grows, the gene is copied into every new cell, so it develops with the desired characteristic.
To make insulin, the plasmid carrying the human insulin gene is put into a bacterium, and the bacteria are grown in large numbers in a fermenter. Each time one divides, the plasmid is copied, so all the offspring make insulin, which is collected and purified. In research on inherited disorders, a harmless virus is often the vector that carries a working allele into a patient's cells.
The vector is the plasmid or virus that carries the gene, not the bacterium.
Percentage increase in yield
In a field trial, an insect-resistant GM variety of a vegetable crop gave a mean yield of 3.6 kg per plant. The non-GM variety gave 3.0 kg per plant. Calculate the percentage increase in yield.
Increase: \(3.6 - 3.0 = 0.6\) kg per plant
Divide by the original (non-GM) value:
\[\text{percentage increase} = \dfrac{0.6}{3.0} \times 100 = 20\%\]
Common mistakes
- Saying GM crops are produced by selective breeding. A gene from another organism is inserted by genetic engineering.
- Writing that herbicide-resistant crops "kill weeds". The farmer sprays the herbicide; it kills the weeds but does not harm the crop.
- Giving a vague objection such as "it is bad". Name a specific concern, such as unknown long-term effects on human health.
- Thinking that putting a working allele into a patient's lung cells stops their children inheriting the disorder. Only the treated body cells change; the gametes still carry the faulty allele.
- Dividing by the new value in a percentage change. Always divide by the original value.
Exam tip
"Evaluate" questions on GM crops or GM medicines need benefits and risks, using any data you are given, then a justified conclusion. Either conclusion can score if your reasons support it.