The big idea
Fertility can be controlled by a variety of hormonal and non-hormonal methods of contraception. Each method stops pregnancy at a different stage: it stops eggs maturing or being released, stops sperm reaching an egg, or stops an embryo implanting in the uterus. You need to explain how each method works and evaluate the methods against each other.
Hormonal methods
| Method | How it prevents pregnancy |
|---|
| Oral contraceptives (the pill) | Contain hormones that inhibit FSH production, so no eggs mature. A pill is taken every day |
| Injection, implant or skin patch | Release progesterone slowly, which inhibits the maturation and release of eggs for months (an injection lasts about 3 months) or years (an implant lasts up to about 3 years) |
| Some intrauterine devices (IUDs) | Release a hormone into the uterus |
Some pills contain oestrogen and progesterone, and others contain progesterone only. A hormone works wherever the blood carries it, so a patch on the skin still affects the ovaries.
Non-hormonal methods
| Method | How it prevents pregnancy |
|---|
| Barrier methods: condoms and diaphragms | Prevent the sperm reaching an egg. A condom covers the penis (or lines the vagina); a diaphragm covers the entrance to the uterus |
| Intrauterine devices (IUDs), such as the copper coil | Prevent the implantation of an embryo |
| Spermicidal agents | Kill or disable sperm. Not very effective alone, so they are used with a diaphragm |
| Abstaining from intercourse when an egg may be in the oviduct | No sperm meet the egg around the time of ovulation |
| Surgical sterilisation | Male: the sperm ducts are cut or tied. Female: the oviducts are cut or tied. Usually permanent |
Evaluating methods
When you evaluate, weigh up these points:
- Effectiveness. With typical use (the way people really use a method, including mistakes), methods that depend on the user every time fail more often: pills can be forgotten, condoms can split, and ovulation is hard to predict. Implants, injections, IUDs and sterilisation do not rely on remembering, so they fail far less.
- Side effects. Hormonal methods can cause side effects such as mood changes, irregular bleeding or a higher risk of blood clots.
- Protection against sexually transmitted infections. Only condoms protect against infections such as HIV, because they stop the exchange of body fluids.
- Reversibility. Sterilisation is usually permanent. After stopping injections it can take months for fertility to return, while an implant can be removed.
- Personal or religious beliefs, and whether a doctor or nurse is needed to fit the method.
Abstaining is one of the least reliable methods: cycle length varies, so ovulation is hard to predict, and sperm can survive for several days inside the woman's body.
Using contraception data
With typical use, 6 out of every 100 women using contraceptive injections become pregnant in a year, compared with 0.8 out of every 100 using a copper IUD. A woman wants to avoid pregnancy for several years. Use the data to compare the two methods.
Percentage of women who do not become pregnant in a year: injection \(100 - 6 = 94\%\); copper IUD \(100 - 0.8 = 99.2\%\)
- The IUD is more effective: once fitted it stays in place for years and needs nothing to be remembered, whereas injections can be missed or given late.
- The copper IUD contains no hormones, so it has no hormonal side effects, but it can make periods heavier and must be fitted inside the uterus by a doctor or nurse.
- Fertility returns as soon as an IUD is removed, but it can take months after the last injection.
- Conclusion: the copper IUD suits her better, but neither method protects against sexually transmitted infections, so she would also need condoms if that is a risk.
Remember
- The pill inhibits FSH, so no eggs mature.
- Injections, implants and patches release progesterone slowly, inhibiting the maturation and release of eggs.
- Barriers stop sperm reaching the egg; IUDs prevent implantation of an embryo (or release a hormone); spermicides kill or disable sperm.
- Only condoms protect against sexually transmitted infections.
Common mistakes
- Calling an IUD a barrier method. It works by preventing implantation, or by releasing a hormone.
- Saying the pill "kills eggs" or "stops sperm". Its hormones inhibit FSH, so no eggs mature.
- Saying an implant releases oestrogen. Implants, injections and patches release progesterone.
- Saying hormonal methods or IUDs protect against infections. Only condoms do.
- Ending an "evaluate" answer without a conclusion. You must give a judgement supported by your points.
Exam tip
"Evaluate" means advantages and disadvantages, using any data given, then a justified conclusion. Apply your points to the person in the question: a new partner points to infection risk (condoms), wanting children later points to a reversible method, and a risk of blood clots points away from pills containing oestrogen.