The big idea
The Earth is about 4.6 billion years old, and nobody was there to measure its first atmosphere. Because the evidence is limited, scientists have theories about what the early atmosphere contained and how it formed, and these theories have changed and developed over time. You need to know one theory, and to be able to use information you are given to evaluate theories.
Why the evidence is limited
- The time scale is huge: the early atmosphere existed around 4 billion years ago, long before anyone could observe or measure it.
- Very few rocks survive from that time; most have been eroded, melted or changed.
- So scientists rely on indirect evidence, such as chemicals in ancient rocks, the gases that volcanoes release today and the atmospheres of other planets.
Theories change when new evidence is found (for example very old rocks, or data from space probes), when new technology lets evidence be analysed in better ways, and when other scientists check and question the ideas.
One theory: the first billion years
- During the first billion years there was intense volcanic activity. The volcanoes released the gases that formed the early atmosphere.
- At the start of this period the atmosphere may have been like the atmospheres of Mars and Venus today: mainly carbon dioxide, with little or no oxygen gas. Volcanic gases contain no oxygen gas, and there were no algae or plants to make any.
- Volcanoes also released water vapour. As the Earth cooled, the water vapour condensed to form the oceans.
- Volcanoes produced nitrogen, which gradually built up in the atmosphere. Nitrogen is unreactive and does not dissolve much in water, so little of it was removed.
- There may have been small proportions of methane (CH₄) and ammonia (NH₃).
- When the oceans formed, carbon dioxide dissolved in the water and carbonates were precipitated, producing sediments. This reduced the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. Calcium carbonate is one example of a carbonate that formed.
You only need to know this theory, but a question may describe another one and ask you to weigh it up using the information given.
Then and now
| Gas | Early atmosphere (this theory) | Atmosphere today |
|---|
| Carbon dioxide | most of the atmosphere | a small proportion (about 0.04%) |
| Oxygen | little or none | about 20% |
| Nitrogen | a small proportion, slowly building up | about 80% |
| Water vapour | large amounts from volcanoes | small amounts that vary |
| Methane and ammonia | possibly small proportions | very little |
When you compare, mention both atmospheres in each point, for example "mainly carbon dioxide then, but only about 0.04% now".
Evaluating evidence and theories
When a question gives you information, ask:
- Which parts support each theory, and which go against it? Quote the data.
- Is the evidence direct or indirect? Volcanoes today may not release the same gases as volcanoes billions of years ago, and another planet is not the Earth.
- Is there enough evidence, and is it representative (one sample, one place)?
- What conclusion does the information support? Theories use words like "may" and "suggests" because the evidence is limited.
Using evidence from ancient rocks
Suppose geologists find a layer of sedimentary rock about 3.8 billion years old that contains pebbles worn smooth and round by flowing water. Explain what this suggests about the early Earth, and give one limitation of the evidence.
- Pebbles are rounded by moving water in rivers and seas, so there was liquid water on the Earth's surface by then.
- So the Earth had already cooled enough for water vapour to condense. This fits the theory that water vapour from volcanoes condensed to form the oceans, although it does not show where the water came from.
- Limitation: one rock layer from one place may not be representative, and its age is an estimate. It also tells us about water, not directly about which gases were in the air.
Common mistakes
- Saying the water vapour "evaporated" to form the oceans. It condensed as the Earth cooled.
- Writing "carbon monoxide" for carbon dioxide, or "ammonium" for ammonia (NH₃).
- Saying the early atmosphere had plenty of oxygen. It had little or no oxygen, because there were no algae or plants yet.
- Saying plants removed the carbon dioxide in the first billion years. In this theory it dissolved in the oceans and formed carbonate sediments; photosynthesis came later.
- Stating a theory as a fact. Write "one theory suggests" or "may have been".
Exam tip
In 6-mark "describe" questions, give the events in time order and name the process at each step (released, condensed, dissolved, precipitated): a list of gases without the processes scores few marks. In "evaluate" questions, give points for and against each theory, mention the limits of the evidence and finish with a judgement.