The big idea
The carbon footprint is the total amount of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases emitted over the full life cycle of a product, service or event. It can be reduced by reducing emissions of carbon dioxide and methane. You need to describe actions that do this, and give reasons why the actions may be limited.
What a carbon footprint includes
- Every greenhouse gas, not just carbon dioxide. Other gases are counted as a carbon dioxide equivalent: a tonne of methane counts as many tonnes of carbon dioxide, because methane has a much stronger warming effect.
- Every stage of the life cycle: getting the raw materials, manufacture, transport, use and disposal.
- It can be worked out for a product (a mobile phone), a service (a bus route) or an event (a football match).
Reducing carbon dioxide emissions
| Action | How it reduces emissions |
|---|
| Alternative energy supplies (wind, solar, hydroelectric, nuclear) | Less fossil fuel is burned to generate electricity |
| Energy conservation (insulating buildings, efficient appliances, LED lights) | Less energy is needed, so less fuel is burned |
| Carbon capture and storage | Carbon dioxide is removed from power station waste gases and stored underground, for example in old oil and gas fields, so it does not reach the atmosphere |
| Carbon taxes and licences | Emitting carbon dioxide costs money, so companies are encouraged to emit less |
| Carbon off-setting, including tree planting | Trees take in carbon dioxide by photosynthesis, balancing some emissions |
Something is carbon neutral when there is no net release of carbon dioxide: any carbon dioxide released is balanced by the same amount being absorbed or offset.
Reducing methane emissions
- Send less waste to landfill, by recycling and composting food waste.
- Collect methane from landfill sites, or make biogas from waste by anaerobic digestion, and burn it as a fuel. Burning turns the methane into carbon dioxide, a much weaker greenhouse gas, and the fuel replaces some fossil fuel.
- Change the diet of cattle so they produce less methane, or farm fewer cattle (people eating less meat and dairy).
- Drain rice paddy fields for part of the growing season.
- Repair leaks from gas pipelines and wells.
Why actions may be limited
- Scientific disagreement about the causes and consequences of global climate change, or a belief that scientists disagree.
- Lack of public information and education about the problem.
- Lifestyle changes: people may not want to drive, fly or heat their homes less, and many lifestyles now involve more car and air travel.
- Economic considerations: alternatives can be expensive, businesses may lose profits or jobs, and developing countries need cheap energy to grow.
- Incomplete international cooperation: not every country agrees to act, so one country's efforts have a smaller effect.
The carbon footprint of an event
A one-day music festival produces: 120 tonnes of carbon dioxide from visitors' travel, 30 tonnes of carbon dioxide from diesel generators and 0.5 tonnes of methane from food waste in landfill. Take 1 tonne of methane as having the same warming effect as 28 tonnes of carbon dioxide. Calculate the carbon footprint. The organisers say that composting the food waste would cut the footprint more than running the stages on solar power instead of diesel. Evaluate this claim.
methane as carbon dioxide equivalent: \(0.5 \times 28 = 14\) tonnes
carbon footprint: \(120 + 30 + 14 = 164\) tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent
Composting could save at most about 14 tonnes, but replacing the generators could save up to 30 tonnes, less the footprint of making and transporting the solar panels. So the claim is probably wrong. Both savings are small next to the 120 tonnes from travel, and that is the hardest part to cut, because the organisers cannot make visitors change how they travel.
Common mistakes
- Defining the carbon footprint as "the carbon dioxide a product releases". Include other greenhouse gases and the full life cycle.
- Calling solar panels "energy conservation". They are an alternative energy supply; energy conservation means using less energy.
- Saying carbon neutral means no carbon dioxide is released. It means no net release.
- Saying carbon capture and storage stops a fuel producing carbon dioxide. It stops the carbon dioxide reaching the atmosphere.
- Giving actions for carbon dioxide when the question asks about methane.
Exam tip
When asked why actions may be limited, give reasons from different groups (scientific, education, lifestyle, economic, international) rather than three ways of saying "it costs too much". In a 6-mark question, give actions for both gases and at least one limitation.