The big idea
A life cycle assessment (LCA) assesses the environmental impact of a product at every stage of its life, from getting the raw materials to throwing it away. Comparing LCAs helps people decide which of two products is better for the environment. But some impacts are hard to put numbers on, and an LCA can be written to give the answer someone wants, so you need to read them critically.
The four stages
| Stage | What is counted (examples) |
|---|
| 1. Extracting and processing raw materials | Mining, quarrying, drilling for oil or cutting down trees; the energy used, damage to habitats, waste rock |
| 2. Manufacturing and packaging | Energy, water and other resources used in the factory; waste and pollution produced |
| 3. Use and operation during its lifetime | Fuel, electricity, water or detergent the product uses while it works |
| 4. Disposal at the end of its useful life | Landfill, incineration or recycling; land used, pollution, materials lost |
Transport and distribution are not a separate stage: they are included at each stage. Every journey by lorry, ship or plane burns fuel, which uses up finite resources and releases carbon dioxide and other pollutants.
For products that use fuel or electricity, such as cars and washing machines, the use stage often has the largest impact. For products used once, such as packaging, raw materials, manufacture and disposal matter most.
Numbers and value judgements
Some effects can be fairly easily quantified (given a number):
- the use of water;
- the use of resources (raw materials);
- the use of energy sources;
- the production of some wastes.
The effects of pollutants are much harder. How much harm does a gas do to people's health, or litter to wildlife? Allocating numerical values to these effects is not straightforward and requires value judgements, so an LCA is not a purely objective process. Two groups studying the same product can reach different conclusions.
Selective LCAs
A selective or abbreviated LCA looks at only some of the stages or impacts. These can be useful for a quick comparison, but they can be misused to reach pre-determined conclusions, for example to support an advertising claim. A company could include only the stages where its product does well and leave out the rest. When you judge a claim based on an LCA, ask which stages and impacts have been left out, and who carried out the assessment.
Comparing plastic and paper shopping bags
| Stage | Plastic bag (poly(ethene)) | Paper bag |
|---|
| Raw materials | Crude oil, a finite resource, processed by fractional distillation and cracking | Wood from trees, a renewable resource, although forests are cut down |
| Manufacture | Polymerisation uses energy, but less energy and water than making paper | Pulping wood uses more energy and much more water |
| Transport | Light and thin, so less fuel is used | Heavier and bulkier, so more fuel is used |
| Use | Strong and waterproof, so it can be reused many times | Tears easily, especially when wet, so it is often used only once |
| Disposal | Not biodegradable: lasts a very long time in landfill, and litter harms wildlife; can be recycled | Biodegradable; can be recycled or composted |
Neither bag is better at every stage. Paper usually has the larger impact in manufacture and transport, and plastic the larger impact at disposal, so the overall result depends heavily on how many times each bag is used.
Keeping a laptop for longer
An LCA for a laptop gives these values: raw materials and manufacturing 300 kg of carbon dioxide; use (electricity) 20 kg of carbon dioxide per year; disposal 10 kg. Compare the carbon dioxide released per year of use if the laptop is kept for 3 years or for 6 years.
Kept 3 years: total \(= 300 + (3 \times 20) + 10 = 370\) kg, so per year \(= 370 \div 3 = 123\) kg
Kept 6 years: total \(= 300 + (6 \times 20) + 10 = 430\) kg, so per year \(= 430 \div 6 = 72\) kg
Keeping the laptop twice as long cuts its carbon dioxide per year by about 40%. Most of the impact comes from making it, so repairing products and using them for longer reduces their impact far more than saving electricity during use. The data cover only carbon dioxide, not other impacts such as the metals mined.
Remember
- The four stages: raw materials, manufacturing and packaging, use, disposal, with transport at every stage.
- Water, resources, energy and some wastes are fairly easy to quantify; the effects of pollutants need value judgements.
- So an LCA is not purely objective, and selective LCAs can be misused, for example in advertising.
Common mistakes
- Naming transport as a separate stage. It is included within every stage.
- Including the cost of the product or how well it works. An LCA is about environmental impact.
- Saying an LCA is objective because it uses data. Giving values to pollutant effects needs value judgements.
- Quoting values from a table without comparing them. Use comparison words: "one product uses twice as much water as the other".
- Assuming the paper bag is better because it is renewable and biodegradable. It has a larger impact during manufacture and transport.
Exam tip
In a six-mark question comparing two products, work through each stage for both products, then give a balanced conclusion. When evaluating an advertising claim, say what is true in it, name the stages it ignores, and conclude that a full LCA is needed.