A power company plans to convert an old coal-fired power station so that it burns wood pellets (biomass) instead of coal.
Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of this change.
Include in your answer:
- the impact on the environment
- the reliability of the electricity supply.
Model answer
Advantages: wood pellets are renewable, because new trees can be planted to replace those that are cut down. The trees absorb carbon dioxide as they grow, so if they are replanted the net carbon dioxide emissions are far lower than from coal, which helps to reduce global warming. Wood also produces much less sulfur dioxide than coal, so there is less acid rain. The company can reuse the existing boilers, turbines, generators and grid connection, which is cheaper and faster than building a new station and keeps jobs in the area. Biomass is also reliable: unlike wind or solar power, the fuel can be burned whenever electricity is needed, so the output can be increased at times of high demand.
Disadvantages: burning wood still releases carbon dioxide and smoke particles at the chimney, and the pellets are often shipped from abroad, so transport adds more emissions. Growing the fuel needs huge areas of forest; if forests are not managed sustainably, habitats can be destroyed. Wood stores less energy per tonne than coal, so much more fuel must be delivered and stored, and the dust from stored pellets is a fire and explosion risk. The station is only reliable as long as ships and trains keep delivering fuel, so a break in the supply chain could stop generation.
Overall the change is better for the environment than coal and keeps a controllable supply, but it is only truly low-carbon if the wood comes from sustainably managed forests.
Explanation
This is marked by levels: the top level needs both advantages and disadvantages, explained, and must cover both the environment and reliability. Strong answers explain why biomass is close to carbon neutral (regrowth absorbs carbon dioxide) and why that depends on replanting and transport. A key reliability point is that biomass, unlike wind or solar, can be burned on demand, but it depends on a steady supply of fuel.