Question 1
1 markA student recorded the minimum temperature, in °C, at her school on four mornings in February.
4 -3 2 6
She wants to work out the geometric mean of these four temperatures.
Explain why the geometric mean of these temperatures cannot be found.
Model answer
The product of the values is \(4 \times (-3) \times 2 \times 6 = -144\), which is negative.
The geometric mean is the fourth root of this product, and a negative number has no fourth root, so the geometric mean cannot be found.
Explanation
The geometric mean of n values is the nth root of their product, so it is only used for positive values such as lengths, prices or growth multipliers. With one negative value among four, the product is negative and has no fourth root. Temperatures in °C can be negative, so an arithmetic mean or the median should be used instead.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for an explanation linking the negative value to the product or the root, eg one of the values (-3) is negative, so the product of the four values is negative (-144) and you cannot find the fourth root of a negative number
oe. Accept 'the geometric mean can only be found for positive values and -3 is negative' or 'the product is negative so it has no fourth root'. 'There is a negative number' with no reference to the product, the root or the geometric mean needing positive values scores B0. Do not accept 'temperatures are not percentages' or 'the numbers are too small'. Ignore any non-contradictory or irrelevant statements.