Question 1
1 markLily wants to estimate the probability that her paper aeroplane flies more than 5 metres when she throws it.
She throws it 20 times in the school hall. It flies more than 5 metres 13 times.
She then throws it 80 times outside on a windy day. It flies more than 5 metres 28 times.
Lily says,
"I have thrown the aeroplane 100 times, so 0.41 is a reliable estimate of the probability."
Give a reason why Lily's estimate may not be reliable.
Model answer
Indoors the relative frequency is \(\dfrac{13}{20} = 0.65\), but outside in the wind it is \(\dfrac{28}{80} = 0.35\).
The throws were not all made in the same conditions (the wind affects how far the aeroplane flies), so they are not repeats of the same experiment. 0.41 mixes two different probabilities and does not estimate the probability for either set of conditions.
Explanation
A relative frequency only settles down towards the probability when every trial is carried out in the same way, so that the probability is the same each time. Lily's 100 throws mix indoor throws with throws in the wind, which give very different relative frequencies. A common error is to say she needs more throws: the problem here is not the number of trials but the change of conditions.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for a reason about the conditions not being the same, eg the throws were not all made in the same conditions (indoors and outside in the wind), so they are not repeats of the same experiment / the wind changes how far the aeroplane flies, so the probability outside is different / the relative frequencies indoors (0.65) and outside (0.35) are very different, so the results should not be combined
oe. The reason must refer to the change in conditions (the wind, or indoors and outside) or to the two very different relative frequencies. Any values stated must be correct (\(\dfrac{13}{20} = 0.65\), \(\dfrac{28}{80} = 0.35\)). Do not accept '100 throws is not enough' or 'she should throw it more times' on its own (more throws do not help when the conditions change), 'the results are random', or 'she made a mistake adding'. Ignore any non-contradictory or irrelevant statements.