Question 1
1 markMia's hypothesis is 'Adults who walk to work have a lower resting pulse rate than adults who drive to work.'
She measures the resting pulse rates of 12 adults who walk to work and 12 adults who drive to work, all from her workplace.
The median pulse rates are 64 beats per minute for those who walk and 71 beats per minute for those who drive.
Which statement is correct?
Choose your answer.
- Her results support the hypothesis, but larger samples would make her conclusion more reliable
- Her results prove that walking to work lowers a person's pulse rate
- Her results show that every walker has a lower pulse rate than every driver
- Her results show that the hypothesis is true for all adults in the country
Model answer
Her results support the hypothesis, but larger samples would make her conclusion more reliable
Explanation
The walkers' median is lower, so the results support the hypothesis, but samples of 12 from one workplace are small, so the conclusion is not very reliable. The results cannot show that walking causes a lower pulse rate (other factors, such as general fitness, may explain it), medians do not describe every individual, and a sample from one workplace cannot be generalised to all adults in the country.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for Her results support the hypothesis, but larger samples would make her conclusion more reliable
Accept any clear indication of this option. Any other answer, or more than one answer, scores B0.