Question 1
1 markA factory has two machines, A and B, that fill bags of flour.
One day, the mean mass of the bags filled by Machine A was 498 g and the mean mass of the bags filled by Machine B was 506 g.
The mean mass of all the bags filled by the two machines that day was 502 g.
What does this tell you about the numbers of bags filled by the two machines that day?
Give a reason for your answer.
Model answer
The overall mean of 502 g is a weighted mean of 498 g and 506 g, weighted by the numbers of bags.
502 is exactly halfway between 498 and 506 (502 - 498 = 4 and 506 - 502 = 4), so the two means have equal weights.
So the two machines filled the same number of bags that day.
Explanation
The mean of two groups together is a weighted mean of the two group means, so it is pulled towards the mean of the larger group. It is exactly halfway between the group means only when the groups are the same size. If Machine B had filled more bags, the overall mean would have been closer to 506 g.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for the two machines filled the same number of bags, with a reason, eg the overall mean (502 g) is exactly halfway between 498 g and 506 g, so the two means must have equal weights
oe. Accept a correct algebraic reason, eg 498a + 506b = 502(a + b) gives 4b = 4a, so a = b. 'They filled the same number of bags' with no reason scores B0. 'Machine A filled more bags' or 'Machine B filled more bags' scores B0. Ignore any non-contradictory or irrelevant statements.