Question 1
1 markThe box plot shows the amounts of money raised by 50 students in a sponsored silence.
Jo says,
"The mean amount raised is probably less than £20."
Do you agree with Jo?
Give a reason for your answer.
Model answer
No, I do not agree with Jo.
The median amount is £20. The median is much closer to the lower quartile (£15) than to the upper quartile (£40), and the right whisker (£40 to £90) is much longer than the left whisker (£5 to £15), so the amounts are positively skewed.
A few students raised large amounts, and these pull the mean up but do not change the median, so the mean is likely to be more than £20.
Explanation
In a positively skewed distribution the values above the median are much more spread out than the values below it. The mean uses every value, so the long tail of large values makes it larger than the median, which depends only on the middle value. Students often mix up the directions: positive skew has its long tail on the right, towards the higher values.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for No (the mean is likely to be more than £20), with a reason, eg the median is £20 and the amounts are positively skewed, so the few large amounts pull the mean above the median
oe. The decision and a reason are both needed for the mark. The reason must use the skew or its features, eg 'positive skew', 'the right whisker is much longer than the left whisker', 'the median is much closer to the lower quartile than to the upper quartile', or 'a few students raised large amounts (up to £90), which increase the mean but not the median'. 'No' with no reason B0. 'Yes' B0. 'No, because the median is £20' with no reference to the skew or the large amounts B0. 'No, the mean is always bigger than the median' B0. Ignore any non-contradictory or irrelevant statements.