Question 1
1 markZara is testing the hypothesis 'Commuters who listen to music on the train feel less stressed than commuters who do not.'
One morning, she asked 12 commuters on one train to rate their stress from 1 to 10.
Which change would most improve the reliability of her conclusion?
Choose your answer.
- Ask a larger random sample of commuters, on different trains and days
- Give each group's mean stress rating to a greater degree of accuracy
- Leave out any stress ratings that do not fit in with her hypothesis
- Present her results in a 3D bar chart with a colour for each group
Model answer
Ask a larger random sample of commuters, on different trains and days
Explanation
Reliability improves with more data, collected so that it represents the population: a larger random sample, taken on different trains and days, reduces the effect of chance and of one unusual morning. Giving the means more accurately does not make the data more reliable, leaving out values that do not fit biases the results, and a 3D chart only changes the presentation (and can mislead).
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for Ask a larger random sample of commuters, on different trains and days
Accept any clear indication of this option. Any other answer, or more than one answer, scores B0.