Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
AQA GCSE Statistics (Higher Paper 2) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
Planning and collecting data
Unit 2
Representing data
Section C: C1a (tabulation, tally, pictogram); Section E: E3d
Tabulation, tallies, pictograms and tables of data
Section C: C1a (pie chart), C1b (comparative pie chart)
Pie charts and comparative pie charts
Section C: C1a (stem and leaf diagram)
Stem and leaf diagrams
Section C: C2 (bar charts, bar line charts, line charts, frequency polygons)
Bar charts, line charts and frequency polygons
Section C: C2 (cumulative frequency charts)
Cumulative frequency diagrams
Section C: C2 (histograms), C3b
Histograms and frequency density
Section C: C2 (box plots); Section D: D3b; Section E: E5b
Box plots and outliers
Unit 3
Summarising data
Section D: D1a (mode, median, arithmetic mean)
Mode, median and mean
Section D: D1a (weighted mean, geometric mean), D1b
Weighted mean, geometric mean and choosing an average
Section D: D2; Section E: E5a
Skewness
Section D: D3a (range, quartiles, IQR, percentiles, interpercentile and interdecile range)
Range, quartiles, percentiles and interdecile range
Section D: D3a (standard deviation)
Standard deviation
Section C: C2 (time series); Section D: D1a (mean seasonal variation), D4; Section E: E6
Time series, moving averages and seasonal variation
Section C: C2 (scatter charts); Section D: D5
Scatter diagrams, lines of best fit and regression lines
Section D: D6; Section E: E9a, E9b, E9c
Spearman's rank correlation coefficient
Unit 4
Probability
Unit 5
Interpreting and evaluating results
Unit 6
Statistical enquiry cycle
3.6 Statistical enquiry cycle: 3.6.1 Initial planning, 3.6.2 Data collection
Statistical enquiry cycle: planning and data collection
3.6 Statistical enquiry cycle: 3.6.3 Processing and presentation, 3.6.4 Interpretation, 3.6.5 Evaluation
Statistical enquiry cycle: analysis and evaluation
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/39

Capture-recapture

Practise 13 exam-style questions on Capture-recapture for AQA GCSE Statistics (Higher Paper 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 13 questions
  • 1–5 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
13 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

1 mark

Crayfish that have been caught once in a pot baited with food are more likely to go into a baited pot again.

A river warden uses capture-recapture to estimate the number of crayfish in a stretch of river, using baited pots for both samples.
She marks 40 crayfish in her first sample. Her second sample has 60 crayfish, and 15 of them are marked.

Which of these is most likely to be the true number of crayfish in the stretch of river?

Choose your answer.

  • 85
  • 140
  • 160
  • 210

Model answer

210
Estimate \(= \dfrac{40 \times 60}{15} = 160\)
Marked crayfish go back into the pots more readily, so the second sample contains more marked crayfish than it should. The estimate divides by the number of marked crayfish in the second sample, so a number that is too big makes the estimate too small. The true number is likely to be more than 160, so 210 is the most likely.

Explanation

Estimate = (number marked × size of second sample) ÷ number of marked animals in the second sample. If marked animals are more likely to be recaptured, that divisor is too large and the population is underestimated, so the true number is probably above the estimate of 160. If marked animals avoided the pots instead, the estimate would be too high.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    B1 for 210

    Any other answer, or more than one answer, scores B0. The capture-recapture estimate is \(\dfrac{40 \times 60}{15} = 160\). Marked crayfish are more likely to be caught again, so the second sample contains more marked crayfish than it should; the divisor (15) is too large, so 160 is too low and the true number is likely to be more than 160. 210 is the only option above 160. 160 ignores the effect of the behaviour; 140 treats the estimate as too high; 85 is only the number of different crayfish caught (40 + 60 - 15).

Question 2

2 marks

Ravi wants to estimate the number of pigeons that live in the main square of a town.

One morning he catches 30 pigeons in the square, puts a ring on each one and releases them.
The next morning he catches 40 pigeons in the square. 4 of them have a ring.

Ravi calculates an estimate of 300 pigeons.

Explain why the capture-recapture method may not give a valid estimate of the number of pigeons that live in the square.

Model answer

Pigeons can fly freely between the square and the rest of the town, so the population in the square is not fixed between the two samples. Some of the ringed pigeons may be elsewhere the next morning, and pigeons that live elsewhere may be in the square. So fewer ringed pigeons may be recaptured than the method expects, and the estimate of 300 is really an estimate of a larger, unclear population - not of the pigeons that live in the square.

Explanation

Capture-recapture assumes a closed population: the same animals are there for both samples, with no movement in or out. Birds that move freely over a whole town break this assumption, so the method suits populations confined to an area, such as fish in a pond or animals on an island.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    B1 for pigeons fly in and out of the square (to and from other parts of the town), so the population is not fixed (not closed)

    oe. Accept 'the pigeons in the square are not the same group each day', 'pigeons from elsewhere in the town visit the square'. Do not accept 'pigeons may be born or die' alone (one day is too short for this to matter much).

  2. 1 mark

    B1 for a consequence, eg ringed pigeons may have flown elsewhere, so fewer are recaptured and the estimate is too high / the estimate is really of all the pigeons that visit the square (or of the town), not those that live in the square

    oe. Accept 'the second sample includes pigeons from outside the square that could not have been ringed'. A second, different valid problem may score this mark instead of a consequence, eg 'one night may not be long enough for the ringed pigeons to mix with the others'. Ignore any non-contradictory or irrelevant statements.

Question 3

3 marks

A class tests the capture-recapture method on a jar of dried beans.

They take out 60 beans, mark each one with a pen and put them back in the jar.
They shake the jar and take out 75 beans. 11 of these beans are marked.

Calculate an estimate of the number of beans in the jar.

The teacher then counts all the beans. There are 450 beans in the jar.
Give one reason why the class's estimate is different from the true number.

Model answer

\(\dfrac{11}{75} = \dfrac{60}{N}\)
\(N = \dfrac{60 \times 75}{11} = 409.09...\), so about 409 beans.
The estimate is lower than 450, so the second sample contained more marked beans than expected. The beans may not have been mixed well enough, leaving many of the marked beans near the top where they were put back.

Explanation

A simulation like this shows that a capture-recapture estimate is only an estimate. Here 11 marked beans out of 75 were caught; if the jar holds 450 beans, about 10 would be expected, so even one or two extra marked beans by chance (or poor mixing) moves the estimate well away from the true number.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    M1 for \(\dfrac{60 \times 75}{11}\) or \(\dfrac{11}{75} = \dfrac{60}{N}\) oe

    oe

  2. 1 mark

    A1 for 409 (or 409.1 or better)

    409.09... Accept 409 or 410 from rounding, or 409 from truncating. Correct answer with no working scores M1A1.

  3. 1 mark

    B1 for a reason, eg the beans were not fully mixed, so too many marked beans were near the top / chance (sampling variation): a different sample would contain a different number of marked beans

    oe. A reason based on the marked beans, eg 'the ink made the marked beans easier to pick out', is acceptable. Reasons must fit an estimate that is too low (too many marked beans in the second sample) or be about chance. Do not accept 'they counted wrongly' with no detail, or 'the estimate is only an estimate'. Ignore any non-contradictory or irrelevant statements.

Question 4

4 marks

A charity estimates the number of grey seals that use a stretch of rocky coast.
Each seal has its own pattern of spots on its fur, so seals can be recognised from photographs.

In a first survey, 92 different seals were photographed.
In a second survey a week later, 63 different seals were photographed. 14 of these seals had also been photographed in the first survey.

Calculate an estimate of the number of grey seals that use this stretch of coast.
Give one advantage of using photographs instead of putting tags on the seals.
State one assumption needed for the estimate to be valid.

Model answer

\(\dfrac{14}{63} = \dfrac{92}{N}\), so \(N = \dfrac{92 \times 63}{14} = \dfrac{5796}{14} = 414\) seals
Advantage: the seals do not need to be caught or handled, so they are not harmed and their behaviour is not changed, and a spot pattern cannot fall off like a tag.
Assumption: the group of seals using this stretch of coast stays the same between the two surveys, with no seals arriving, leaving, being born or dying.

Explanation

Photo-identification is capture-recapture with natural marks: a seal photographed twice is a 'recaptured marked' animal. It avoids problems caused by physical marks, but the usual assumptions still apply: a closed population and an equal chance for every seal of being photographed.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    M1 for \(\dfrac{92 \times 63}{14}\) or \(\dfrac{14}{63} = \dfrac{92}{N}\) oe

    oe. The seals photographed in the first survey play the part of marked animals.

  2. 1 mark

    A1 for 414

    Correct answer with no working scores M1A1. 155 (92 + 63) scores M0A0. 141 (92 + 63 - 14, the number of different seals photographed) scores M0A0.

  3. 1 mark

    B1 for an advantage, eg the seals do not have to be caught or handled (so they are not harmed or frightened) / the marks (spot patterns) cannot be lost / being photographed does not change their behaviour

    oe. Do not accept 'it is cheaper' or 'it is easier' with no further explanation.

  4. 1 mark

    B1 for an assumption, eg the number of seals using this stretch of coast does not change between the surveys (no births, deaths or seals arriving or leaving) / every seal is equally likely to be photographed in each survey / seals are always recognised correctly from their spots

    oe. Accept 'the seals mix between the surveys'. Do not accept 'the photographs are good' with no link to recognising seals. Ignore any non-contradictory or irrelevant statements.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.