Question 1
1 markCrayfish that have been caught once in a pot baited with food are more likely to go into a baited pot again.
A river warden uses capture-recapture to estimate the number of crayfish in a stretch of river, using baited pots for both samples.
She marks 40 crayfish in her first sample. Her second sample has 60 crayfish, and 15 of them are marked.
Which of these is most likely to be the true number of crayfish in the stretch of river?
Choose your answer.
- 85
- 140
- 160
- 210
Model answer
210
Estimate \(= \dfrac{40 \times 60}{15} = 160\)
Marked crayfish go back into the pots more readily, so the second sample contains more marked crayfish than it should. The estimate divides by the number of marked crayfish in the second sample, so a number that is too big makes the estimate too small. The true number is likely to be more than 160, so 210 is the most likely.
Explanation
Estimate = (number marked × size of second sample) ÷ number of marked animals in the second sample. If marked animals are more likely to be recaptured, that divisor is too large and the population is underestimated, so the true number is probably above the estimate of 160. If marked animals avoided the pots instead, the estimate would be too high.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for 210
Any other answer, or more than one answer, scores B0. The capture-recapture estimate is \(\dfrac{40 \times 60}{15} = 160\). Marked crayfish are more likely to be caught again, so the second sample contains more marked crayfish than it should; the divisor (15) is too large, so 160 is too low and the true number is likely to be more than 160. 210 is the only option above 160. 160 ignores the effect of the behaviour; 140 treats the estimate as too high; 85 is only the number of different crayfish caught (40 + 60 - 15).