Question 1
1 markIn a group of 40 students, 25 play football and 18 play hockey.
Explain why some of the students in the group must play both football and hockey.
Model answer
If no student played both sports, there would be at least \(25 + 18 = 43\) students in the group. There are only 40, so at least \(43 - 40 = 3\) students must play both football and hockey: the two circles of a Venn diagram must overlap.
Explanation
In a Venn diagram, n(F) + n(H) counts the students in the overlap twice. If the two sets did not overlap, F and H together would contain 43 students, which is more than the whole group of 40. So at least 3 students must be in both sets.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for \(25 + 18 = 43\), which is more than 40, so (at least 3) students must be counted in both groups
oe, eg 'on a Venn diagram the circles would hold at least 43 students if they did not overlap, but there are only 40', 'at least 3 students play both'. The sum 43 (or the difference of 3) and a comparison with 40 are needed. Do not accept 'some people like both sports' or 'it is likely' with no use of the numbers.