Question 1
1 markA train company recorded the main reason for each of 80 complaints it received in one month: late trains, crowded trains, dirty trains, ticket prices or rude staff.
Ravi drew a line chart of the results, with the five reasons along the horizontal axis and the number of complaints on the vertical axis. He joined the points with straight lines.
Give a reason why a line chart is not suitable for these data.
Model answer
The reason for a complaint is qualitative (categorical) data. The five reasons have no natural order and there are no values between them, so the lines joining the points do not represent anything; listing the reasons in a different order would give a completely different line. A bar chart (or a pie chart) would be suitable.
Explanation
A line chart joins points with lines, which only makes sense when the horizontal axis has a numerical order, such as time, so that the line shows how one value changes into the next. Categories such as reasons for complaints should be shown with separate bars. Saying only that another chart is 'better' does not give a reason.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for the data are qualitative (categorical): the reasons are categories, so the lines joining the points have no meaning / there is nothing between one reason and the next
oe, eg 'the reasons are not in any order, so the slope of a line from one reason to the next means nothing'; 'putting the reasons in a different order would change the shape of the line'; 'line charts are for numerical or time data, not categories'. Accept 'he should use a bar chart because the data are categorical'. 'A bar chart would be better', 'it is hard to read' or 'it looks messy' with no statistical reason scores B0. 'The data are discrete' on its own scores B0 (the point is that the data are categories, not numbers). Ignore any non-contradictory or irrelevant statements.