Question 1
1 markA food factory checks the temperature in its cold store every hour.
The temperature must never go above 5 °C.
The manager wants a measure of spread to summarise one week of temperatures.
Give a reason why the range would be more useful to the manager than the interquartile range.
Model answer
The manager needs to know whether the temperature ever went too high, so the extreme temperatures matter. The range uses the highest and lowest temperatures, but the interquartile range only describes the middle 50% of the readings, so a dangerously high temperature in the top 25% would not affect it.
Explanation
The interquartile range is usually preferred because it is not affected by extreme values, but here the extreme values are exactly what the manager needs to know about. The choice of a measure of spread should depend on its purpose: for a safety limit, the highest and lowest values, and so the range, are what matter.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for the manager needs to know about the extreme (highest) temperatures, and the range uses them, but the interquartile range ignores the top and bottom 25% of the readings / a temperature above 5 °C would not show up in the interquartile range
oe. Must refer to the extreme or highest temperatures mattering here. 'The range is easier to work out' scores B0. 'The range uses all the data' scores B0 (it uses only two values).