Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/30

The development of the model of the atom

Practise 18 exam-style questions on The development of the model of the atom for AQA GCSE Combined Science (Physics Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 18 questions
  • 1–6 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
18 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

Describe the plum pudding model of the atom.

Model answer

The plum pudding model suggested that the atom is a ball of positive charge with negatively charged electrons embedded in it.

Explanation

In the plum pudding model there is no nucleus: the positive charge and the mass are spread out through the whole atom, and the electrons are scattered through it like plums in a pudding.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    the atom is a ball of positive charge

    allow positive charge spread throughout the atom

  2. 1 mark

    with (negative) electrons embedded in it

    allow electrons scattered through it / dotted through it

Question 2

2 marks

Give the name of the particle whose existence was shown by the experimental work of James Chadwick, and state where this particle is found.

Model answer

James Chadwick's work provided the evidence for neutrons, which are found in the nucleus.

Explanation

Chadwick's evidence for the neutron came about 20 years after the nucleus became an accepted scientific idea. It explained why the mass of most nuclei is greater than the mass of their protons alone.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    neutron

  2. 1 mark

    in the nucleus

Question 3

3 marks

The model of the atom has changed several times since scientists first thought atoms were tiny spheres that could not be divided.

Explain why scientific models of the atom change. Use one example in your answer.

Model answer

Scientific models change when new experimental evidence is found that the existing model cannot explain. The model is then changed or replaced by one that explains all of the evidence. For example, the results of the alpha particle scattering experiment could not be explained by the plum pudding model, so it was replaced by the nuclear model.

Explanation

Models in science are always open to change. A model is kept while it explains the evidence; when new results disagree with its predictions, scientists adapt it or replace it. The history of the atom is a clear example of this process.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    new experimental evidence is found

    allow new discoveries / experiments

  2. 1 mark

    that the existing model cannot explain, so the model is changed or replaced

    allow the new model must explain all the evidence

  3. 1 mark

    a correct example, e.g. the alpha particle scattering experiment led to the nuclear model replacing the plum pudding model

    allow the discovery of the electron led to the plum pudding model; allow Chadwick's evidence for neutrons

Question 4

4 marks

In an alpha particle scattering experiment, alpha particles were fired at a thin gold sheet. A detector counted how many alpha particles were deflected through different angles. The table shows the results.

Use the data to explain what the experiment showed about the structure of the atom.

Table with columns "Angle of deflection", "Number of alpha particles detected". Angle of deflection: Less than 10°; Number of alpha particles detected: 98 400 | Angle of deflection: 10° to 30°; Number of alpha particles detected: 1 500 | Angle of deflection: 30° to 90°; Number of alpha particles detected: 95 | Angle of deflection: More than 90°; Number of alpha particles detected: 5.

Model answer

Almost all of the alpha particles (98 400 out of 100 000) were deflected by less than 10°, so they passed almost straight through the gold. This shows that most of the atom is empty space. Only 5 alpha particles were deflected by more than 90°, bouncing back towards the source. This shows that the mass and positive charge of the atom are concentrated in a very small nucleus at the centre, which only a very few alpha particles came close to.

Explanation

Link each pattern in the data to a conclusion: the huge number of small deflections shows that most of the atom is empty space; the tiny number of large deflections shows a small, massive, positively charged nucleus. Quoting numbers from the table makes the answer stronger.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    almost all of the alpha particles were deflected through less than 10° / passed almost straight through

    allow 98 400 of 100 000 / 98.4%

  2. 1 mark

    so most of the atom is empty space

  3. 1 mark

    only a very small number (5) were deflected by more than 90° / bounced back

  4. 1 mark

    so the mass and positive charge are concentrated in a very small nucleus at the centre

    allow there is a tiny, positively charged, massive nucleus

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Revision notes

The development of the model of the atom

The big idea

Atoms are far too small to see, so scientists use models to describe them. A model is kept while it explains the evidence. When new experimental evidence turns up that the model cannot explain, the model is changed or replaced. The model of the atom has changed several times, and the most important change came from the alpha particle scattering experiment.

How the model changed

  1. Tiny spheres: until the electron was discovered, scientists thought of atoms as tiny spheres that could not be divided.
  2. The plum pudding model: the discovery of the electron (in 1897) showed that atoms contain smaller particles. Atoms are neutral, so they must also contain positive charge. The plum pudding model suggested that the atom is a ball of positive charge with negative electrons embedded in it.
  3. The nuclear model: the results of the alpha particle scattering experiment (about 1909) showed that the mass of an atom is concentrated at the centre, in a nucleus, and that the nucleus is charged. This nuclear model (Rutherford's model, 1911) replaced the plum pudding model.
  4. Bohr's model: Niels Bohr adapted the nuclear model by suggesting that electrons orbit the nucleus at specific distances. His theoretical calculations agreed with experimental observations, so his idea was accepted.
  5. Protons: later experiments showed that the positive charge of any nucleus can be divided into a whole number of smaller particles, each with the same amount of positive charge. These particles were named protons.
  6. Neutrons: the experimental work of James Chadwick (1932) provided the evidence that neutrons exist in the nucleus. This was about 20 years after the nucleus became an accepted idea.

You do not need the details of the experiments by Bohr or Chadwick.

Diagram of the plum pudding model of the atom: a large sphere of positive charge (shaded, with + signs) with 10 small negative electrons (−) spread through it. There is no nucleus. "Ball of positive charge" labels the large sphere of positive charge; "Negative electron" labels one of the small negative electrons spread through the sphere.
The plum pudding model: positive charge, and the mass, spread through the whole atom, with no nucleus.

The alpha particle scattering experiment

A beam of alpha particles (which are positive) was fired at a very thin sheet of gold foil, in a vacuum so that air did not absorb them. A detector was moved around the foil to count how many alpha particles were deflected through each angle.

Diagram of alpha particle scattering: alpha particles travel from left to right towards a small positive nucleus at the centre. One path passes far from the nucleus and goes straight on, undeflected. One path passes fairly close to the nucleus and is deflected through a small angle (about 25°). One path heads almost straight at the nucleus and is deflected back the way it came (through about 155°). One path passes far from the nucleus and goes straight on, undeflected. One path passes close to the nucleus and is deflected through a large angle (about 95°).
Alpha particles passing a gold nucleus: the closer one passes to the nucleus, the stronger the repulsion and the bigger the deflection.
What was observedWhat it showed
Most alpha particles passed straight through the foilThe atom is mostly empty space: most alpha particles never came near a nucleus
Some were deflectedThe positive charge is concentrated in a small region, which repels alpha particles that pass close to it
A very small number bounced backMost of the mass and the positive charge are concentrated in a tiny nucleus. Very few alpha particles head almost straight at something so small

The plum pudding model could not explain these results. With the positive charge and the mass spread through the whole atom, nothing is concentrated enough to push an alpha particle back: they should all pass through with very little deflection. Electrons cannot do it either, because their mass is far too small.

Testing a different model

Suppose the nucleus had a radius of 1/10 of the atom's radius, instead of less than 1/10 000. Predict how the results of the scattering experiment would be different.

The nucleus would be a much bigger target, so many more alpha particles would pass close to a nucleus and be repelled strongly.

So far fewer alpha particles would pass straight through, and many more would be deflected through large angles or bounce back.

In the real experiment, only a tiny fraction bounced back (roughly 1 in every several thousand), which shows that the nucleus must be very small compared with the atom.

Comparing the two models

Plum pudding modelNuclear model
Positive chargeSpread throughout the atomConcentrated in a tiny nucleus
MassSpread evenly through the atomMostly concentrated in the nucleus
ElectronsEmbedded in the positive chargeOutside the nucleus, at a distance from it
Empty spaceNone: a solid ballThe atom is mostly empty space

In both models the atom contains negative electrons and has no overall charge. The plum pudding model was not useless: it explained the evidence of its time, and testing its predictions is what led to the nuclear model.

Common mistakes

  • Giving the plum pudding model a nucleus. It has no nucleus: the positive charge is spread through the whole atom.
  • Saying the alpha particles bounced off electrons. Electrons have far too little mass; the alpha particles were repelled by the positive nucleus.
  • Saying the nucleus attracted the alpha particles. Both are positive, so they repel.
  • Mixing up the scientists: Bohr put electrons at specific distances; Chadwick provided the evidence for neutrons.
  • Describing only one model in a "compare" question. Give matching points for both models.

Exam tip

For "explain why the model changed" questions, link each observation to its conclusion: straight through means empty space, deflected means a concentrated positive charge, bounced back means the mass is concentrated in a tiny nucleus. Say what the plum pudding model predicted, and why the results did not fit it.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.