Question 1
2 marksScientists investigated the source of the oxygen released in photosynthesis. They used the heavy isotope of oxygen, ¹⁸O, which can be detected and measured.
In two experiments, they supplied a single-celled alga with water and carbon dioxide containing different percentages of ¹⁸O. They then measured the percentage of ¹⁸O in the oxygen released by the alga. The table shows their results.
What can you conclude from these results? Explain your answer.
Model answer
The oxygen released comes from the water, not from the carbon dioxide. In both experiments the percentage of ¹⁸O in the oxygen released (1.19% and 0.41%) is almost the same as in the water (1.20% and 0.40%), and it does not match the percentage in the carbon dioxide (0.40% and 1.20%). This is because the oxygen is produced by photolysis of water.
Explanation
If the oxygen came from carbon dioxide, its ¹⁸O content would follow the carbon dioxide; instead it matches the water in both experiments, so the oxygen comes from water split by photolysis. Swapping which substance was enriched in the second experiment is what makes the conclusion convincing. Support the conclusion with figures from the table.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
The oxygen released comes from water (and not from carbon dioxide)
Accept 'the oxygen is produced by photolysis of water'. Reject 'oxygen comes from carbon dioxide'.
-
1 mark
The percentage of ¹⁸O in the oxygen released is (almost) the same as in the water (1.19 and 1.20, 0.41 and 0.40) in both experiments
Accept 'the percentage in the oxygen changes when the percentage in the water changes'. Accept 'it is not the same as in the carbon dioxide (0.40 and 1.20)'. Data or a clear comparison with the water are needed.