Question 1
2 marksRead the following passage.
Silk is made from the cocoons spun by silkworms, the larvae (caterpillars) of a moth. Male silkworms produce about 20% more silk than females, so silk farmers would like to rear only males. However, male and female larvae look almost identical.
In moths, sex is determined by the Z and W chromosomes. Males have two Z chromosomes (ZZ) and females have one Z and one W chromosome (ZW). The W chromosome carries very few genes.
A gene on the Z chromosome affects the skin of the larvae. The dominant allele, T, gives opaque, white skin. The recessive allele, t, gives translucent skin, through which some of the internal organs can be seen.
Breeders cross males with translucent skin and females with opaque skin. Workers then sort the larvae by their skin and remove the unwanted larvae before they spin cocoons.
In a trial, 600 larvae from this cross were sorted by skin type, and their sex was checked later, when they had become pupae. Of the 304 larvae with opaque skin, 301 were male. Of the 296 larvae with translucent skin, 289 were female.
Use the information in the passage and your own knowledge to answer the following question.
Three of the larvae with opaque skin were female (paragraph 5).
Suggest two explanations for this result.
Model answer
1. The workers may have made mistakes when sorting the larvae, for example judging slightly translucent skin to be opaque.
2. A mutation from t to T may have occurred in the father's sperm, so these females inherited a Z chromosome carrying the dominant allele T.
Explanation
In this cross a female should never have opaque skin, because her only Z chromosome comes from her father, who has two copies of t. Unexpected results are usually explained by errors in observation or recording, by the parents not being as stated, or by rare mutations. When asked for two suggestions, give two different ideas, because extra wrong ones cancel correct ones.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A worker made an error when sorting / judged the skin type wrongly / larvae were mixed up after sorting
Max 2. 1 mark for each different explanation. List rule: if more than two explanations are given, each wrong or contradictory extra explanation cancels one correct explanation.
-
1 mark
An error was made when checking the sex of the pupae
-
1 mark
A mutation (from t to T) occurred in the male parent's gamete / on the Z chromosome these females inherited from their father
Accept 'a mutation in the larva'. Reject 'the larvae mutated to become opaque'.
-
1 mark
The female parent had mated with a male carrying T / the larvae came from a different cross
Accept 'a different father'.
-
1 mark
Skin appearance is also affected by another gene (e.g. an epistatic gene)
-
1 mark
Skin appearance is also affected by the environment, e.g. diet / temperature