Question 1
2 marksRead the following passage.
Some sea slugs feed on green algae in an unusual way. A slug pierces an algal cell and sucks out its contents. Most of the cell contents are digested, but the chloroplasts are taken up intact by the cells lining the slug's highly branched gut, which spreads out just beneath its thin, flat body surface. In one species, these stolen chloroplasts continue to absorb light and fix carbon dioxide for several months.
Scientists investigated whether the chloroplasts help the slugs to survive when food is scarce. They collected 40 slugs that had just fed and kept them without food in sea water at 15 °C. Twenty slugs had 12 hours of light each day and twenty were kept in continuous darkness. After 60 days, the mean mass of the slugs in the light had fallen from 24.0 mg to 19.2 mg. The mean mass of the slugs in the dark had fallen from 23.8 mg to 13.1 mg.
In an alga, most chloroplast proteins are coded for by genes in the nucleus of the algal cell. Chloroplast proteins are continually damaged, broken down and replaced. In the slug, the stolen chloroplasts gradually lose their ability to photosynthesise.
Use the information in the passage and your own knowledge to answer the following question.
Calculate the percentage decrease in the mean mass of the slugs kept in the dark (paragraph 2). Give your answer to 3 significant figures.
Model answer
Decrease in mean mass = 23.8 - 13.1 = 10.7 mg
Percentage decrease = 10.7 ÷ 23.8 × 100 = 44.96 = 45.0% (3 significant figures)
Explanation
Percentage change = change ÷ starting value × 100, so divide the decrease (10.7 mg) by the starting mass (23.8 mg), not by the final mass. To 3 significant figures the answer is 45.0: the final zero is significant, so 45 is not enough. The slugs kept in the light lost only 20.0% of their mass, which suggests that their stolen chloroplasts supplied some of the organic substances that they respired.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
Correct method: (23.8 - 13.1) ÷ 23.8 × 100; or a correct final answer of 45.0 (%) with no working
A correct answer of 45.0% with no working scores 2 marks. Accept for 1 mark: 45 or 44.96 or 44.958 (not given to 3 significant figures) OR 0.450 (not multiplied by 100) OR evidence of 10.7 (the decrease in mass) with an incorrect final answer. Do not award this mark for 81.7 (the decrease divided by the final mass, 13.1) or for 20.0 (the percentage decrease of the slugs kept in the light).
-
1 mark
45.0 (%)
Do not accept 45 or 44.96 for this mark (3 significant figures are needed). Ignore a minus sign.