Question 1
3 marksDoctors examined three tumours, J, K and L, removed from three different patients. The table shows some of their observations.
Which tumour is malignant? Give two pieces of evidence from the table that support your answer.
Tumour L was found inside the skull. Suggest why tumour L could be life-threatening even though it is not malignant.
Model answer
Tumour K is malignant. It grows much faster than J and L: its volume doubles in 65 days, compared with 350 and 420 days. Also, cells from K have been found in nearby lymph nodes, so K has spread.
The skull cannot expand, so as tumour L grows it presses on the brain tissue (and its blood vessels), which can stop parts of the brain working.
Explanation
Malignant tumours grow rapidly, have no capsule, contain unspecialised cells with abnormal nuclei and can spread (metastasise) through the blood or lymph. Benign tumours grow slowly inside a capsule and do not spread, but they can still be dangerous when they press on vital organs such as the brain. Evidence must come from the table, so compare K with J and L rather than just listing features of malignant tumours.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
K grows faster / doubles in volume in a shorter time (65 days compared with 350 or 420 days)
Max 1 if the answer does not identify K as the malignant tumour. Max 3. Points 1 to 4: 1 mark each, max 2 from these points. List rule: if more than two pieces of evidence are given, each wrong or contradictory extra piece cancels one correct piece. Accept 'K grows quickly' for point 1 only if it is linked to the doubling time in the table.
-
1 mark
K has no capsule (so its cells are not contained / can invade nearby tissue)
Accept 'K is not encapsulated'.
-
1 mark
Cells of K are unspecialised / have large, irregular nuclei (unlike the surrounding tissue)
Accept 'cells of K are not like the cells of the tissue around it'. Accept 'poorly differentiated'.
-
1 mark
Cells from K are found in (nearby) lymph nodes, so K has spread / metastasised
Accept 'K can spread to other parts of the body (through the lymph)'. Insufficient: 'K is in the lymph nodes' (the tumour itself is not in the lymph nodes).
-
1 mark
L could press on / compress the brain (tissue) / blood vessels / nerves, because the skull cannot expand OR as it grows it could damage brain tissue and stop the brain working normally
Accept 'there is no space for it to grow inside the skull, so it puts pressure on the brain'. Ignore 'it could become malignant' unless linked to pressure or damage. Reject 'L could spread to other parts of the brain' (L is benign).